Here’s another in our series of interviews with a swath of Academy voters from different branches for their candid thoughts on what got picked, overlooked, and overvalued this year.
Best Picture of the Year
“The Shape of Water” has broad appeal, is a beautifully done film, and feels like a completed thought and singular vision from all categories and disciplines working together. “Get Out” is a very good and fun movie but not necessarily best picture material.
As far as omissions, “Victoria & Abdul,” came and went without the usual fanfare for Oscar nominations. I’m not sure why it was left out of most categories, including Judi Dench and Stephen Frears. Also, “Detroit” seemed like an early frontrunner and was mysteriously left out.
Also, in terms of the preferential system, I’m not sure of its effectiveness, it’s so hard to say one way or the other.
Best Picture of the Year
“The Shape of Water” has broad appeal, is a beautifully done film, and feels like a completed thought and singular vision from all categories and disciplines working together. “Get Out” is a very good and fun movie but not necessarily best picture material.
As far as omissions, “Victoria & Abdul,” came and went without the usual fanfare for Oscar nominations. I’m not sure why it was left out of most categories, including Judi Dench and Stephen Frears. Also, “Detroit” seemed like an early frontrunner and was mysteriously left out.
Also, in terms of the preferential system, I’m not sure of its effectiveness, it’s so hard to say one way or the other.
- 2/23/2018
- by Bill Desowitz
- Indiewire
Similar News
The Big Pitch: What Do Ryan Gosling & Emily Blunt Have Planned For ‘The Fall Guy’?
- 4/18/2024
- by Hollywood Outbreak
- HollywoodOutbreak.com
Blumhouse & Universal’s ‘Wolf Man’ Adds Matilda Firth
- 4/18/2024
- by Anthony D'Alessandro
- Deadline Film + TV
‘The Jinx’ Filmmakers Revisit That Robert Durst Confession: “We Screamed”
- 4/18/2024
- by Jackie Strause
- The Hollywood Reporter - Movie News
Her and Blade Runner 2049’s Dystopias Get Closer Thanks to New ‘A.I. Girlfriends’ Market
- 4/18/2024
- by David Crow
- Den of Geek
Czech Sci-Fi Noir Restore Point available now on Digital Download in the UK!
- 4/18/2024
- by Peter 'Witchfinder' Hopkins
- Horror Asylum
Oscar Nominee Filmmaker Threw the Script of Peter Weller’s $54 Million Movie in Trash Before His Wife Changed His Mind
- 4/17/2024
- by Rahul Thokchom
- FandomWire
Daniel Craig’s Casino Royale Established a James Bond Trend After 19 Years That Would’ve Made Ian Fleming Proud
- 4/16/2024
- by Sreshtha Roychowdhury
- FandomWire
Judi Dench recalls first meeting with Pierce Brosnan: 'Adorable man, glorious to work with'
- 4/12/2024
- by Agency News Desk
- GlamSham
Spotlight: National Literacy Trust's Celebrity Supporters
- 4/11/2024
- Look to the Stars
IMDb.com, Inc. takes no responsibility for the content or accuracy of the above news articles, Tweets, or blog posts. This content is published for the entertainment of our users only. The news articles, Tweets, and blog posts do not represent IMDb's opinions nor can we guarantee that the reporting therein is completely factual. Please visit the source responsible for the item in question to report any concerns you may have regarding content or accuracy.
More to explore
‘The Witcher’ Renewed For 5th & Final Season At Netflix
- 4/18/2024
- by Denise Petski
- Deadline Film + TV
Henry Cavill Says ‘Maybe I’m Too Old Now’ to Play James Bond as Fake Movie Trailer With Him as 007 Goes Viral With 2.5 Million Views
- 4/18/2024
- by Zack Sharf
- Variety - Film News
Quentin Tarantino Scraps ’The Movie Critic’; Brad Pitt Would Have Reprised Cliff Booth Role From ‘Once Upon A Time In Hollywood’
- 4/17/2024
- by Rodrigo Perez
- The Playlist
Martin Scorsese’s Long-Gestating ‘Sinatra’ Film With Leonardo DiCaprio Adds Jennifer Lawrence
- 4/17/2024
- by Christopher Marc
- The Playlist
Director Steven Spielberg Is Quietly Planning Another Movie About Aliens
- 4/17/2024
- by Rafael Motamayor
- Slash Film
‘Scream’ Actors Support Fired Co-Star Melissa Barrera at ‘Abigail’ Premiere: ‘It Says a Lot About How True the Love Is’
- 4/18/2024
- by Marc Malkin
- Variety - Film News
Henry Cavill Says ‘Maybe I’m Too Old Now’ to Play James Bond as Fake Movie Trailer With Him as 007 Goes Viral With 2.5 Million Views
- 4/18/2024
- by Zack Sharf
- Variety - Film News
Selena Quintanilla Deserves to Be Celebrated This Year - Not Exploited
- 4/16/2024
- by Lucas Villa
- Popsugar.com
Bad Bunny's First NYC Show From His Most Wanted Tour Is Proof His Latine Fans Still Come First
- 4/12/2024
- by Johanna Ferreira
- Popsugar.com
Olivia Rodrigo's "Guts" Tour Made Me Feel Like a Teen Again
- 4/8/2024
- by Yerin Kim
- Popsugar.com
Cannes Directors’ Fortnight Title ‘Eephus’ Picked Up by Film Constellation (Exclusive)
- 4/18/2024
- by Leo Barraclough
- Variety - Film News
Participant’s Box Office Past Shows Why Its Closure Is Such a Loss: ‘It Didn’t Fail, It Just Ran Its Course’
- 4/18/2024
- by Tom Brueggemann
- Indiewire
Netflix Will Stop Regularly Telling Us How Many Subscribers It Has
- 4/18/2024
- by Brian Welk
- Indiewire
Netflix Blows Away Wall Street by Adding More Than 9 Million Subscribers in Q1
- 4/18/2024
- by Tony Maglio
- Indiewire
‘Challengers’ Review: Zendaya Rules This Love Triangle
- 4/18/2024
- by Gregory Ellwood
- The Playlist
‘Aang: The Last Airbender’ Delayed to 2026, ‘Transformers One’ Moves Back a Week
- 4/18/2024
- by Rebecca Rubin
- Variety Film + TV
Quentin Tarantino Scraps ’The Movie Critic’; Brad Pitt Would Have Reprised Cliff Booth Role From ‘Once Upon A Time In Hollywood’
- 4/17/2024
- by Rodrigo Perez
- The Playlist
Martin Scorsese’s Long-Gestating ‘Sinatra’ Film With Leonardo DiCaprio Adds Jennifer Lawrence
- 4/17/2024
- by Christopher Marc
- The Playlist
Director Steven Spielberg Is Quietly Planning Another Movie About Aliens
- 4/17/2024
- by Rafael Motamayor
- Slash Film
Sundance Film Festival Courting New Host City for 2027 and Beyond
- 4/17/2024
- by Matt Donnelly
- Variety - Film News
‘The Witcher’ Renewed For 5th & Final Season At Netflix
- 4/18/2024
- by Denise Petski
- Deadline Film + TV
‘For All Mankind’ Renewed for Season 5, Soviet Space Program Spinoff in the Works at Apple TV+
- 4/17/2024
- by Joe Otterson
- Variety - TV News
‘Oldboy’ English-Language TV Series in the Works From Park Chan-wook, Lionsgate
- 4/17/2024
- by Joe Otterson
- Variety Film + TV
‘Elsbeth’ Nabs Second Season on CBS
- 4/18/2024
- by Rick Porter
- The Hollywood Reporter - Movie News
‘NCIS: Origins’ Casts ‘Longmire’ Vet as Gibbs’ Father
- 4/18/2024
- TV Insider