Add a Review

  • dromasca10 November 2022
    I am fascinated by the French films made in the last years of the sixth decade of the 20th century. The revolution in the art of cinema that was to be the Nouvelle Vague was about to break out, and in almost all the films made in the years '57 - '59 one can glimpse the signs of the smoldering volcano. 'Des femmes disparaissent' is the second feature film made by Édouard Molinaro, a prolific and successful director who was not associated with the New Wave. His long career would evolve towards lighter and more luminous films than this violent drama with many 'film noir' elements set in a single night in a labyrinthine, crime-haunted city that could be Marseilles. The title is very didactic, one of the most uninspired movie titles I've come across, but behind it and despite the prologue written in about the same tone hides a social drama with excellently profiled characters. There are elements of modern cinematography that make watching this film an interesting experience not only for cinema history buffs but also for viewers of a wider audience.

    The film begins as a neighborhood drama, in an atmosphere somewhat similar to Italian neorealist films. Pierre and Beatrice are two young people from a proletarian background. They are neighbors, in love and engaged. Beatrice wants to go out for a night out, reclaiming her independence, at least until marriage. Pierre is jealous and follows her, but a couple of gangsters are watching the place where the girls gather for the party and attack the young man. Stubbornly, he continues the pursuit and his fears prove to be well founded. The party is an opportunity to recruit young women for prostitution and 'export' across the Mediterranean. The confrontation between Pierre and the mobsters increases in intensity, and from here the film takes on the allure of a film noir, with the hero alone facing the violence of the bandits in an attempt to save his beloved.

    Revisited more than 60 years after its making, the film is uneven, mixing elements of beautiful cinematography with old-fashioned details that haven't held up as well over time. The story is simple and takes place over the course of a few hours of the same night, which makes it attractive and easy to follow. There is also a crescendo in the story and a quickening of the pace towards a memorable final scene. The generic and the cinematography are well done, building a 'film noir' atmosphere. The music is exceptional - jazz performed by percussionist Art Blakey and his band, outstanding jazz artists, among those who performed in France in the 1950s. Less successful are the sets, especially in the outdoor scenes. Filming took place, it seems, entirely in studios and the cardboard sets seem almost visible. La Nouvelle Vague that had just begun that year 1959 would almost completely sweep away this style of filming, still extremely used in French films of the 50s. Some very interesting actors also appear. Robert Hossein, a complex actor, today unfairly forgotten, plays the main role. His Pierre is a positive hero who does not disguise his shadows. Estella Blain who plays the role of Beatrice looks a lot like her generational colleague, Brigitte Bardot. She would prioritize her career in music, and die quite young. The bad guys are also represented individually and with shades of humor. I especially noticed Philippe Clay, an actor that I do not think that I had ever met before. This film made at a turning point in the history of cinema offers quite a few good reasons for viewing or re-watching even today.
  • Director Molinaro at the start of his career put out a few unmemorable thrillers and noirs, of which DES FEMMES DISPARAISSENT is an example. The film opens with a condemnation of female trafficking, but there is very little of that in the film. Instead, what you get is a not particularly bright lead (Hossein), his very pretty girlfriend (Blain) who does not do much apart from showing off her physical attributes, and two excellent villains (whose names I cannot tell from the IMDB cast list because the respective photos are missing) involved in shootouts, fisticuffs, power displays, sex, and abductions.

    As indicated earlier, Hossein is not the sharpest knife, but nothing prepares you for his stupid decisions, whereby one moment he has the upper hand, next he is at his nemesis' mercy. The worst moment is when he hands the gun to Blain, tells her to shoot the villain, and he gets a stick to try to reach a gate key which the baddy had thrown away. After seeing a few of those incredibly infantile decisions, I really had to make an effort to watch the rest. I could not wait for the end, which came rather lukewarm.

    Good photography contrasts with very poor, totally unrealistic, punchup sequences. The script borders on the pathetic. In real time, it is not a long film. It just seems overlong.

    Not recommended.
  • White slave trade was a trendy subject at the time.It's Edouard Molinaro's second film and like the first one "le Dos au Mur" ,and the follow-up ("Un Témoin Dans la Ville" )it's a thriller.It would be 1960 before Molinaro made a truly worthy film noir:"La Mort de Belle" from Simenon.

    Robert Hossein portrays a man whose fiancée mysteriously disappeared.There's a house where girls are invited:they promise them anything:to become a top model,to travel around the world,all that in a chic atmosphere ,a perfect lure .

    Best performance comes from Jane Marken,as Mrs Cassini,a woman who pretends to help the hero whereas...The actress could epitomize evil as few of her peers could do ("Manèges" by Yves Allégret).

    Average.
  • One of the first features directed by Édouard Molinaro, in black and white, is a boring drama in the first half and a continuous shift of gun and machine gun bursts in the second half. A very young and not very convincing Robert Hossein in a dirty love affair, that has a lot of troubles because of the woman he loves, and Magali Noël (Fellini's favorite), as a woman who encourages the dangerous links between some young, unconscious and naive women, and some unscrupulous, tricky men.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    Currently deciding on what title with my favourite actress Michele Mercier should be watched for the ICM French Viewing Challenge,I took a look at the movies with Mercier's regular co-star Robert Hossein I had waiting to view. Finding dbdumonteil's review to be very inviting,I choose to find out how shameful the road is.

    View on the film:

    Credited as an "Assistant editor", Michel Deville's regular co-writer/editor Nina Companeez makes her distinctive mark on editor Laurence Mery-Clark's cutting style, in outstanding, jarring smash-cuts giving the fight scenes a blunt edge,and Companeez's smash-cuts for unexpected confrontations Rossi faces giving them a from out of nowhere sense of surprise. Loitering around like a street rat, Robert Hossein gives a excellent performance as the dead-eyed Noir loner Rossi, whose stubbornness to brush off the threats from gangsters has Hossein gives Rossi a rough and tumble manner, shoving aside any thug blocking him from his dame love. Slithering round the drugged dames, (which includes a very good Magali Noël as Coraline Merlin) Philippe Clay is an utter creep as gangster Tom. Carrying a wry smirk, Clay has Tom hand out punishment to "trouble" with an abrasive strike that puts anyone who speaks up back in line.

    Drugging all the women to join the white slave trade, director Edouard Molinaro & cinematographer Robert Juillard give the hazy state a quality touch of sleaze, exposing the bare flesh of the sexy ladies, and giving the fight scenes peculiar tools (the only Noir where plant pots are used as weapons?) Jazzing up the dark side streets with a breezy Jazz score from Art Blakey, Molinaro ignites an excellent seedy Film Noir atmosphere, panning the long streets Rossi drags his heels down, and in tightly coiled shots holds Tom lurking in the shadows set to pounce on Rossi. Welding the editing styles of Clark and Companeez with ease, Molinaro superbly matches the elegance of panning shots round the house with frenzied close-ups,whip-fast tracking shots and fast-moving wide-shots stylisation smashing into Rossi's face. Set over one night, Albert Simonin and Gilles Morris-Dumoulin's adaptation of Morris-Dumoulin's own novel tensely place Rossi and Tom as two sides of the same Noir loner coin, via Rossi being drained of nothing else to care for but holding his dream woman again, while Tom has long ago beaten up any remains of remorse or regret for a desire to go up the black market food chain,as they both walk down the road to shame.
  • Before his hit comedies, Molinaro began his career with interesting thrillers : his first one "Le Dos Au Mur" (you will never forget the ending, promised), his second "Des Femmes Disparaissent" (you will never forget the filthy Jane Marken and Philippe Clay as a very very bad guy, promised again), his third and first masterpiece "Un Témoin Dans La Ville" (with stunning cinematography and Lino Ventura as a very very unforgettable bad guy) and "La Mort De Belle" (his second masterpiece adapted from Simenon). "Des Femmes Disparaissent" is really exciting : two gangsters with ambiguous relations dealing young pinups in body slavery. For a movie directed in 1959, some scenes shocked me. Yes, between 1958 and 1961, Edouard Molinaro directed these fine thrillers, the last one not being available on DVD. Edouard Molinaro just left us, two weeks after George Lautner. So long, messieurs...
  • A sensitive theme, a lot of action scenes, a dark affair versus pure love and a young Robert Hossein as a sort of Prince Charming.

    After decades, only a decent film defined by good intentions because the thrill, emotion and presumed tension are the only basic ingredients.

    The cliches, in manicheic skin are more than present and the unrealism of few scenes are sources of smiles. But it is only a modern fairy story, predictable and interesting for the some virtues of image.

    Warning about dirty love affaires, the good one versus bad guys, fight scenes - obvious too many - and some twists. Testimony about a time and about the early years of Edouard Molinaro career.