Lizzie Borden
Bridget Sullivan
Hosea Knowlton
Emma Borden
George Robinson
Andrew Borden
Sylvia Knowlton
Dr. Bowen
Abby Borden
Mayor Coughlin
Alice Russell
Julien Ralph
Adelaide Churchill
Andrew Jennings
Store Proprietor
Judge Blaisdell
Marshall Hilliard
Dr. Wood
Bailiff
Mrs. Raymond
Eli Bence
Justice Morgan
Dr. Draper
Hannah Reagan
Young Lizzie
Store Customer
Companion
Townsman (uncredited)
Courtroom Spectator (uncredited)
Policeman Allen (uncredited)
Judge (uncredited)
Jury Foreman (uncredited)
Juror (uncredited)