Mickey Schwerner
Rita Schwerner
James Chaney
Fannie Lee Chaney (as C.C.H. Pounder)
Dennis (as André Braugher)
Hatchet-Faced Man
Sue
Deputy Winter
Hollis Watkins
Andrew Goodman
Emmett White
Matt Suarez
Ben Jr.
Ronald Allred
Lyle (as Walt Goggins)
Ida Flowers
Charlie Parham (as Tom Gossom)
Newsreporter
Rev. Jenkins
Wilbur Combs
Barbara Chaney
Lyle's Father
Betty Combs
Sam (as Tom Nowiki)
Bob Moses
Charlie's Wife
Klansman #2
Older White Woman
Woman Heckler (as P.J. Shinnal)
Klansman #3
Older Black Woman
Barber (as Alonza Ward)
Older Black Man
Sharecropper
Courthouse Photographer (uncredited)
Reggie (uncredited)