The West Side Waltz (1995 TV Movie) User Reviews (7)

Pretty harmless

[HotToastyRag · 5/10 · 27 June 2017]

I'm not really sure how to categorize this movie. It's a friendship movie, it's supposed to be a comedy, it's supposed to be a drama, it's mostly about older people, and it's one of those "older person and younger person help each other" movies. And, pretty much every twenty minutes, the screen fades to black, making you think it's the end, but the movie keeps going. Each section seems to take a new direction, so it's not really a comedy or a drama or a romance or a tearjerker.

If a movie with a handicapped Shirley MacLaine, a socially awkward Liza Minnelli, a homeless Kathy Bates, and a heavily made-up Jennifer Grey, all helping each other with friendship appeals to you, give it a whirl. It's only 90 minutes, and even though it's a little dated, it won't hurt you.

It's not about me...I live on the east side!

[mark.waltz · 7/10 · 5 June 2017]

I've always identified with both Shirley MacLaine and Liza Minnelli, and while I may not share their Oscar win, I do share with Shirley the kookiness, the crotchety moods as I age, and a curiosity of what's beyond what we see immediately around us. With Liza, I relate to her enthusiasm, curiosity about others who seem to share my vision of life, and a fantastic view of hope through my dreams. To see these two ladies together is a dream, in the film version of a play that had marked Katharine Hepburn's Broadway career. Since Hepburn didn't get to repeat her stage role on screen, I'll take MacLaine, as well as Minnelli in Dorothy Loudon's part.

The role of the reclusive widow Margaret seems tailor made for Shirley, stubborn yet lonely, and Liza is her quirky neighbor and only companion. Along comes the Madonna dress-alike Jennifer Grey who takes a job as MacLaine's companion/assistant, at first with Minnelli's jealous objection, and as the three (reluctantly) get to know each other, a friendship of sorts begins. To add a trio into the Oscar winners, Kathy Bates is like a Greek chorus, the local bag lady seemingly as nutty as a Payday bar and filled with a few surprises of her own. MacLaine, as usual, shows a big heart underneath her grumbling, and it's nice to see Liza showing a bit of the grouchy persona as well.

Obviously, the script has been brought up to the current day, showing various New York locations as they were in the mid 1990's, just as crowded as it is now, yet not as spic and span in the process of the Giuliani cleanup. Among the women seen in the clutch of old biddies snubbing Shirley (practically ignoring her when she drops her cane) are Estelle Harris and Mary Pat Gleason, having amusing side discussions on changing sexuality's and morals. TV favorites Robert Pastorelli ("Murphy Brown") and Richard Guilland ("Designing Women") are the two major male co-stars, giving their own unique interpretation of various New York personalities. The plot and style are somewhat stage, but with the talent involved, this is a slice of life drama with moments of comedy that just can't be ignored.

Liza Shines

[nicknortelli · 10/10 · 30 May 2004]

This wonderful and well-written story is highlighted by fine acting and excellent use of the setting, New York City's West Side.

Liza's performance was absolutely brilliant and one is immediately reminded that she is, after all, an academy award winning actress of immense talent. Kathy Bates is also utterly convincing as a homeless woman. Shirley McLaine was an excellent choice for her role. I imagine it must have been difficult to portray a woman whose physical disability gradually worsens during the course of the movie.

When I noticed this movie while flipping through channels, I hadn't planned on doing more than scanning the first few minutes. It pulled me in and I invested 2 hours watching it. Time well spent!

Endearing and Marvelous!

[pmac1978 · 10/10 · 31 March 2005]

I remember seeing this film when it originally aired. Thanksgiving night of 1995. I fell in love with the characters. It really is a New York City film. The titles open with glorious Aeriel shots of the world trade center, central park, and the busy envrioment of west 72nd street.

Shirley Maclaine and Liza Minnelli are perfect foils for each other. Maclaine is delightful as the curmudgeonly Margaret Mary Elderdice . Made Bitter by time, her late husband and former room mate (who committed suicide when the bills got too high). Liza Minnelli cuts the mustard in this flick. Her portrayal of Cara is proof positive that she is indeed a very talented actress. Quite capable of playing great character roles. Not one trace of "LIZA" is on screen. Jennifer Grey is adorable (and quite stunning, albeit with the help of a plastic surgeon. Just watch Dirty Dancing and you'll see what I mean) . She displays great comic timing and is a good balance for her two very seasoned leading ladies. In the end Waltz is a story about the human condition, Self discovery, making peace within one's self and finding one can change . It is a tale of growing friendship . My only complaint was...I wanted more! Mr.Thomspon should be commended for rendering a top notch adaptation of his already clever and heart-warming stage play.

For the longest time it was only possible to find this flick on Lifetime. Usually about 3 am in the morning. This past winter it was released on DVD . Grab it if you can.

Simply wonderful

[selffamily · 9/10 · 31 October 2009]

This is another of those well kept secrets that the movie world hide from us. Heaven only knows why. I found it almost by accident and started watching in trepidation, after all, the star rating it had been given was quite low. At first I didn't recognise Liza Minnelli, but when I did (albeit only a few seconds) I was amazed and impressed. As a previous writer has said, we forget she is an Oscar-deserving actor sometimes because we see her type cast so often. Shirley Maclaine seems to have become type cast now as a grumpy old girl, which is a shame because she does crazy so well too! Kathy Bates' cameo was lovely and the younger woman carried her role well too (sorry, bad with names). In all a well done, subtle and enjoyable film. I shall no doubt seek it out again.

Worth catching for an excellent Liza Minnelli performance

[Capboy · 10/10 · 22 September 1999]

Originally a Broadway play with Katharine Hepburn and Dorothy Loudon, "West Side Waltz" is one of those projects that should have remained on the stage. However, Liza Minnelli is wonderfully cast against type as a reserved, albeit needy, 50ish type longing for companionship. She is the only reason to see this movie, as MacLaine is a bore and Jennifer Grey is simply annoying.

Heartwarming

[chanslor · 9/10 · 8 February 2021]

I don't know why this gets such low reading. It has a wonderful cast, a great script, and I didn't see anything wrong with the filming. The only thing missing is an R rating. It is heartwarming and reflects reality. Probably why it doesn't sell. People don't like to be reminded of their mortality.