Character error

Male calico cats are rare or non-existent enough to make the term "male calico" an oxymoron. The male cat named Calico (voiced of Jon Lovitz) is a tabby, not a calico.

Continuity

The cats test their formula successfully on Scott. But within minutes, he shows no effects when holding Lou.

Crew or equipment visible

On the pier when the phone is ringing you can see a man leaning in from the left side of the screen.

Revealing mistakes

Lou the beagle is a male dog, and in most scenes a male dog is shown. However, in two belly-scratching scenes a female double is seen.

Factual errors

When the dog agents are trying to break into Professor Brody's Lab, the camera shot changes to the dog's point of view. He explains that he doesn't know which wire to cut (as all of his vision is in black and white), but dogs do not see in black and white - their only visual impairment is that they see in the same way as a human with color blindness.

Revealing mistakes

When the cats drive into the factory you can see the tire marks from previous takes. It is extremely unlikely that such marks would be caused by normal slower moving traffic, especially considering the erratic route.

Continuity

When Scotty is kicking the soccer ball, after tryouts, in the back yard, at first his net is square with an ex in the middle of it placed next to a wall. When the shot is panned out, the net is circular with no ex and is in an open part of the yard.

Continuity

When the cats pull up to the gate of the flocking company in the limo, there are two men standing and talking on the other side. A moment later, when the limo drives through they are nowhere to be seen.

Factual errors

When the dog cuts the hole in the barn floor, technically, when he returns down the hole ("and for God's sake, don't forget to wag those tails") the cut out circle should have fallen back down as there was nothing holding it in place.

Continuity

When the Brodys are held hostage by Mr. Tinkles, Calico disappears from Mr. Brody's shoulder in the reverse shots.

Continuity

As the cats are driving the limo into the factory grounds the same hubcap falls off four times.

Continuity

When Brody comes upstairs after missing his son's soccer game, he is wearing a complex face mask, with lots of wires. In silhouette, seen from outside, the visor and wires are missing.

Continuity

When the cats are driving the limousine into the flocking plant the hubcaps disappear and reappear several times.

Continuity

The ninja's goggles disappear and reappear between shots during the fight.

Continuity

In the first scene of the movie, the Brody's car pulls up in front of the house. As it does this, a jogger jogs up to the car and is level with the front of it when the shot changes. The next shot shows the car stopping at the side of the road, and the jogger jogs up to the car again.

Continuity

When the lead cat announces all the factory workers are fired, and states, "Cats Rule," the blinds are then closed. The camera then shows the blinds open on the next shot from inside the room.

Character error

The cat referred to as Russian Blue is not a Russian Blue at all. Russian Blues have green eyes and this one had copper eyes, possibly making it a Chartreux.

Crew or equipment visible

Human driver can be seen from distant shots while driving on the factory grounds.

Revealing mistakes

When Butch is complaining about the mix up with Lou, he says that Lou is so young that he still has his "you know whats", implying that Lou has not yet been neutered. However, the dog playing Lou is clearly neutered.

Continuity

In the Pie Mom's house, Buddy runs upstairs following the cat and turns corner. We get a closeup of the dog's eyes first, followed by a wide shot of the hall; the cat is sitting at the end of the hall. In the very next close-up shot, the cat is up on all fours. The power cord of the table lamp also changes position between shots.

Continuity

When Mr. Tinkles is first introduced, the cats he is speaking to hide under the table when the maid suddenly comes into the room. However in the next shot when the table is shown again, the other cats are nowhere to be seen. They then reappear when Mr. Tinkles is being carried out of the room by the maid.

Factual errors

When the hole is cut in the floor of the barn to insert the new puppies a large circular saw is used to cut a circular hole. This sort of saw cannot cut this sort of hole.

Audio/visual unsynchronised

When Mrs. Brody was surprised to see Lou and Stealth poop thinking he pooped on the carpet, she said in exclaim "Lou!" but her mouth doesn't move.

Continuity

When the Russian Blue throws the spike bomb at Lou and Butch, it explodes, wrecking the entry hall and the entire living room beyond. However, the spikes were geared in a circular fashion, meaning they launched in every direction, not just the hall and living room. The dining area behind the cat is completely undamaged, and during changes in the viewpoint, parts of the living room flip back and forth between damaged and repaired.

Audio/visual unsynchronised

In the beginning of the film when the Brodys pull up to their house, the jogger running by says hello to them, but her lips don't move, nor does she face the family's car or general direction.