User Reviews (2)

Add a Review

  • In a Mexican rural environment Julio Bracho developed the novel of the Italian D'amicis and considered in the neat presence of Lopez Tarso as the perfect school teacher, the conscience of every student, the novel seems to be very large for a Mexican movie at the sixties, that's way sometimes someone could have the impression that Bracho intended to tell many stories in a very short time, situation that doesn't help at all to the film, however the movie is not boring, but appears to be that with this director and a good adaptation of the novel we could hope something better, maybe the most rewarding thing in the film are some views of the Mexico city in the sixties,a curios detail: the children singing at chorus the Emilio de Urang song La Negra Noche without being this and infantile song years later another children sing the same song with Cantinflas in El Profe a movie with a similar topic.
  • pv6119 October 2011
    Warning: Spoilers
    Both 1939 and 1963 versions have been supposedly based on the same book, ''CORAZON'' by Edmundo D'Amicis, and I say supposedly because there is a difference between them. As I have not read the book, don't know who changed what, Alejandro Galindo or Julio Bracho.

    1939: The teacher knows his pupils and tries to help them as much as he can. Not only teaches them their lessons but teaches them to become better persons. So much that in the end, after a very important test, some of them are rewarded with scholarships and medals.

    1963: The teacher arrives as a substitute after the old teacher dies. He learns about each kid and tries to help them as much as he can. Not only teaches them their lessons but teaches them to become better persons. One of the kids, leaves the town to go to the big city searching for his mother, who works there.

    Both movies are very good. But I still think the remake was not necessary.