The Island : Critic Reviews

50
Metascore (38 reviews)
Provided by Metacritic.com
70
Kirk Honeycutt The Hollywood Reporter
Starts off an aggressively derivative sci-fi thriller, then morphs into an above-average chase melodrama.
63
James Berardinelli ReelViews
There's enough fun to be had that it's almost possible to ignore the stupidity of the story and the cavity that replaces character development.
60
Justin Chang Variety
Frenetic actioner about refugees from a genetic cloning plant starts off intriguingly, burns up its ideas in the first hour and pads out the rest with joltingly repetitive action sequences.
60
Dennis Lim Village Voice
This is pure essence of Bay--it's big, it's loud, it has no context, and if you show up tanked, I'm sure it's really quite poetic.
50
Richard Schickel Time
For all the menace of its techno-prattle, its implicit boosts for humanism and its swell production design, the picture is finally a bore. Sci-fi was more powerful when its special effects were cheap and crude, its ideas simple but potently stated.
50
Lisa Schwarzbaum Entertainment Weekly
The Island begins with a whimper of interest as a cool-hued, cautionary exploration of the ethics of cloning, and ends, in a hail of product placement, with a dumb bang.
50
Bill Gallo Dallas Observer
As usual, Hollywood hitmeister Bay is more interested in blowing stuff up than in addressing deep questions like the morality of science and the false myths of civilization, and these explosions go on for over two hours.
50
Scott Foundas L.A. Weekly
Nary an original idea abounds in The Island.
50
Allison Benedikt Chicago Tribune
Classic Bay, except it's missing the crass director's fine-tuned rhythm, his feel for adrenaline, his breakneck edits and sense of humor.
50
Desson Thomson Washington Post
The best thing about The Island is this: Ewan McGregor and Scarlett Johansson, buffed and dressed in sparkling white, wondering how and when to kiss each other.

More Critic Reviews