Rev. Robert Hunt
Edward Maria Wingfield
Capt. John Smith
Capt. Christopher Newport
Older Nathaniel Peacock / Narrator (voice)
Elizabeth Hunt
Oliver Brown (as Phillip Whiteman)
Matthew Fitch
Nathaniel Peacock
Parishioner
Thomas Hunt
Soldier #1 (as Dana Bogdanski)
Jonas Profit
Sailor
Father Casso
John Martin
Mrs. Treadwell
Capt. Bartholomew Gosnold
Parishioner (as Shaun Hall)
George Somers
Carpenter
Messenger
John Ratcliffe
Richard Haklyut
William Love
William Bruster
John Taylor
Thomas Hanham
George Kendall
Anas Todkill
Little Elizabeth Hunt
Musician
George Percy (as Timothy Smith)
Raleigh Gilbert
George Popham