Lyddie Cottrell
Sarah Cain
Bill Alexander
Norma (as Yolanda Wood)
Madison Miller
Bryan Ford
Waiter
Lady Tourist (as Micaela T. Nelligan)
Bishop Stoltzfus
Caleb Cottrell
Anna Mae Cottrell (as Danielle Chuchran)
Josiah Cottrell
Hannah Cottrell
Miriam Esh
Samuel King (as John Cruz)
Charles Eberley
Joseph King
Ada King
Sol King
Secretary
Quigley
Teacher (as Susan Dolan)
Courtney (as Caitlin Meyer)
Amanda
Stacey
Coach Doyle
Fire Captain
Fireman
Young Man
Jerry Kitchel
Homeless Man
Police Officer #1
Responding Officer
Levi King
Amish woman
Principal (uncredited)
Zach (uncredited)
Amish Mother (uncredited)
Amish Friend (uncredited)