One of Wiseman's 3-1/2 hour opuses, this one settling in to the Idaho State Legislature for another round of inquisitive and patient observation. Two juxtapositions stood out in particular. One began with a confrontation between a state senator and a Latino man arguing for immigrants' rights. The two become stuck on a long loop of assertion and have nothing resembling a conversation. The senator's message is predictable. Several scenes later we see a bunch of little Mexican girls doing a hat dance in the atrium of the legislature - a security guard looks down at it and almost imperceptibly shakes his head. The second comes toward the very end, when there is a debate on whether to pass a motion opposing same-sex marriage. The motion is defeated, with each person giving their reasons, and with rationales almost exclusively based on procedural precedent and differing priority. This scene comes between a quiet conference between the senate speaker and two businessmen coming to seek advice, and a prayer-and-bagpipe ceremony for a deceased colleague, and this plus this plus this made me think that Wiseman was proposing a new wrinkle on the church-and-state conundrum - for these people, the forms and practice of government ARE their religion.
Add a Review
-
jonathan-5777 June 2007
-
vanquishinggod15 June 2007State Legislature was a very insightful movie. I recommend this movie to anybody who wonders if the average citizen could do what a politician does. This documentary shows the good and the bad of a legislative body composed almost entirely (if not entirely) of citizens. The viewer is exposed to many committees and inner workings of Idaho's state legislature.
At some point, you realize what someone says in the beginning: that these people who are legislating policy for the state are just average people with a concern for their community and state. These people are not "experts" or paid policy makers. While they have every resource at their fingertips, it seems at though they start out on whatever issue it is they are doing with about as much knowledge on that issue that you or I have right now. It is only through listening to and reading all the sides of an issue from constituents, experts, lobbyists, and everything else that these people start to get a feeling as to what, in their minds, is or would be best. They draw from history as well.
Some parts of this movie are slower than others but the viewer is rewarded by quite a few surprises and changed minds from the legislators themselves .quite rare in this day.
This documentary is obviously not for everybody. Even those in government might find it a bit boring. But for those who enjoy watching the process and are curious about the "what ifs" of their state legislature, this is the movie for them. Sometimes scary, other times fascinating, and still at other times funny, this movie can really help one understand a little bit about what it is to be a citizen-politician. -
film_riot6 November 2007Frederick Wiseman's State Legislature" reaches a length of about four hours, in which he deals with the day-to-day activities of the Idaho Legislature. He shows committee meetings, debates of the House and Senate, informal discussions, meetings with lobbyists, constituents, the public and the press. In between Wiseman cuts images of life in the parliament or of children performing songs there. What made "State Legislature" so impressive for me was the dedication and devotion of the legislators to the process of political work, because it's the effort people like these give, that is an essential key for a democratic process. The legislators work there voluntary and many of them without getting a financial gain from it. For the understanding of this film, it doesn't matter if you are agreeing with the arguments that are produced. I didn't in many cases. Much more interesting is the process of getting to a solution. Frederick Wiseman's "State Legislature" succeeds in showing the advantages and disadvantages of democratic processes.