Add a Review

  • Sure, while the 2020 romantic movie titled "My Birthday Romance" was indeed a watchable and enjoyable movie, it was at the same time still a very stereotypical and generic movie for this particular genre.

    What made "My Birthday Romance" was having an interesting storyline, one that was light-hearted and yet managing to having a very realistic feel to it. Sure, it was an archetypical sappy romantic story, but hey that is what these movies are like.

    Something that definitely also made "My Birthday Romance" work, was the chemistry on the screen between the lead actress Ali Cobrin and actor Jesse Hutch. They were so nicely cast for the movie and they really wear great together on the screen. Both of them had a very believable aura to their performance.

    It was also nice to see Garry Chalk on the screen in this movie, and he was also nicely cast for his role.

    If you enjoy romantic movies, then I will definitely recommend that you sit down to watch the 2020 movie "My Birthday Romance" from writer John Hartman and director Heather Hawthorn Doyle.

    A movie such as this usually falls out of my normal spectrum of genre that I watch. But this was definitely an enjoyable movie.

    My rating of "My Birthday Romance" lands on a six out of ten stars.
  • Jackbv12310 March 2021
    The fake boyfriend (fiance, sometimes even husband) is an extremely common premise in movies and romance novels. Everyone has a good idea that there is going to be a falling out and then how it's going to end.

    I enjoyed the couple. I'm not familiar with Ali Cobrin but I really enjoyed her character. I've seen plenty of Jesse Hutch. These two fit well together. They seemed natural in the role they were playing.

    Some minor negative points: the sets were obviously low budget. Once when Callie and Will are dancing, she is only slightly moving and at times it doesn't look like he is moving at all. He might have swayed a whole 2 inches back and forth.
  • Although not strictly a Hallmark movie but that is the genre that we're talking about here. As such the plot is pretty well worn and there are better versions floating around. The acting is decent as is the chemistry between the various cast members. Dialog slightly above average.

    I watched the whole thing and suffered no stomach discomfort and no regrets in the end. Didn't even hit the fast forward once. If you're in the mood for a little romance movie you could do worse.
  • rebekahrox8 March 2021
    Warning: Spoilers
    The fake boyfriend romance trope is one of my favorites and has resulted in some of the funniest and most romantic Hallmark movies made. Among them, My Fake Fiancé, Holiday in Handcuffs, Holiday Date, Snow Bride, Surprised by Love, Holiday Engagement, and many more. I was really looking forward to this one. What a bust.

    This movie was completely ruined by Callie's dysfunctional parents. And dysfunctional in a not humorous way. They were smothering, overbearing, and controlling. They were on her every. Single. Minute. To get a boyfriend even when she flat out told them that she didn't need a man to be happy and that she was concentrating on building her business. She is constantly set up on blind dates by them and her sister. Usually in these romances that feature inappropriate over-involvement in grown children's lives, one of the spouses is the voice of reason and provides some balance and common-sense advice to the other parent. Not so in this one. I don't know which of the two parents was more offensive. Possibly the mother, because she made a big point of confiding to Callie that she made her husband wait to marry until she finished grad school. Her desperation to get Callie married did not make sense. And it was made more annoying because Callie, our heroine(?), did not nip it in the bid like any other 35 year old woman would have. She should have quit being so nice and told them flat out to BACK OFF. If they refused, cut off communication until they get the message.

    Instead she finds a fake date to her birthday party to get her parents off her back, but instead the parents are on them like vultures. They treat them as if they are madly in love, making them kiss, and immediately act like marriage was right around the corner, instead of just a date she has only known for a week. They publicly toast the happy couple at the Birthday in front of everyone. They make her make a speech when she doesn't want to and she ends up spilling the truth in a way that humiliates her whole family and herself as well.

    She actually declares she wishes that she really was Will's girlfriend, because being his fake girlfriend was just so awesome. By the way, Will is mysteriously absent from most of the party and later Carrie starts looking for him after the debacle and is surprised and disappointed he had left. Then 5 minutes later, when he told her he heard her speech, she says she thought he had gone by that time. Lazy writing. Well it all ends as you would expect. But it was just such a painful journey.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    Yes I mean literally lost my appetite. I made sushi for dinner and started eating while the movie started, and I literally lost my desire for sushi. That's a big deal for me lol.

    Yes I know it's Hallmarkish- Yes I know it's a fairly cookie cutter formula, when has it not been done, daughter 'hires' someone to play her boyfriend to get family off her back. This was so awful, there was zero dialogue from them besides harrassing her to get a date, or hook up with one of their friends etc. Like seriously, you can stick a side story or sub plot or some other substance in a movie, even Hallmark, besides this. Even if they are annoying in that regard, the producers didn't have to make that 100% of the dialogue for 90 minutes. A) It's totally not realistic. B)it makes for really painful TV, like poke your eyes out or ears bleed TV.

    So if this kind of thing irritates you then don't watch this.

    SEcondly but probably more importantly, the protagonist is supposedly a caterer? And again, Hallmark, I get it. Weve seen and ive stomached some pretty sorry examples of bakers or chefs displaying their skills. Like Cringeworthy. OK I cook for a living so I have a keen eye for details or degree of authenticity. And the writers don't have to make it look like the real commercial kitchen, and most often they don't anyway. But come on, do a little research. Or have stepped foot in a kitchen at least once before you make the focal point of her story being a caterer. From precooking a souffle at x in the morning and then complaining that it fell? Hello, you don't even have to be a trained chef to know you dont 'precook' a souffle. Or cooking pasta but when the helper girl pulls a piece out of the pot to check if it's al dente, A) she throws it against the wall- hello, we dont do that in commercial kitchens, B), the water is not even simmering or rolling or moving.

    And then when the 'fake' boyfriend comes into her catering kitchen she dumps her dish all over him, forgive me if I wasn't looking closely but it didn't look like veal parmigiano.

    No chemistry between anyone. Acting skills seemed to have been left at the door.

    And on and on. Again, the premise of 'hiring' a fake boyfriend for a party is a common plot and I've seen it done well, it's not a bad plot. But this just missed every mark, every single mark. No redeeming qualities about this. Would give it a zero or less if I could.
  • bee-debxg22 February 2021
    Even for this type of so predictable-romance-kind of annoying movie that you just put on while you're checking your phone, this one is just terrible! Starting with the terrible toxic family - I mean this is a movie from 2020 and we're still talking about pressuring a successful woman into a relationship, because "how could she be happy if not with a man???".. I'm so annoyed with this movie I took the time to review it!!!! Not great acting but also not terrible... But the story is sooooo ******* bad!!!
  • A vacation to romance--a dessert of delight. Ali showed her acting chops. Who could not love Ali Cobrin? Choosing between her catering future and relational desert was played well by Cobrin.

    The direction by Doyle showed a delicate skill portraying relational awkwardness and angst. Slow at first, the screenplay evolved into a delightfully predictable conclusion. Sea horses indeed.

    Thanks for this romantic interlude. Sometimes love is this rich, delectably rich.
  • Bad dialog. Bad story. Bad acting except for Charles Cottier who plays the brother Will. He reminds very much of a young David Arquette.

    It's just a terrible and painful movie.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    Neither wants a partner - they go on a couple of fake dates over two weeks - share nothing about one another except he likes chicken parmesan - they then magically fall in love(????). Terrible story. Meh acting. All around poor movie.
  • Warning: Spoilers
    Just take note, this is a 7+ movie, so it's little more than a childrens fairy tale. With all these type of movies, the two main characters don't embrace till the end. This particular movie, the catering kitchen is clean as, Callie is seen in silk PJs which I'm sure still has a purchase label on them, even more noticeable is she is wearing a bra. The "big" 35th birthday party, like there is Covid restrictions only allowing 10 people. So, a quaint movie for the children (girls mainly) and then quickly forgotten.
  • sambolebon19 July 2023
    Warning: Spoilers
    This movie was another level bad. Usually I like the benign predictability of this kind of romance but this one was a tough watch. Ultimately it's the writing, just dreadful dialogue, but also how it was directed. There were long pauses and so many awkward moments that there was not one second of believability. The dancing at the party was soooo cringe. I felt sorry for the actors because so often what comes across as bad acting is actually terrible writing. Not that any of them are winning any acting awards either though the brother, Kyle, did stand out as slightly better. Here's the spoiler (haha) I'm not sure many modern couples declare their love after a few fake dates, a basis of lies and one mega awkward kiss! Super super rubbish.
  • Was not expecting.such a wonderful movie... The chemistry between the two lead is really phenomenal.. The stuttering at the very beginning and the uneasiness. And the supporting actors really add flavour to the script. Don't understand why people find this so tedium but it was sprightly on the money. A must watch movie.
  • Apart from a couple of errors in dialogue regarding the time frame and the pro's soufflé naivety, this movie is pretty realistic (eg the obsession with age 35 cut off when it comes to finding a partner). There's about the right amount of awkwardness in the 'fake' couple and the other relationships - the family are loving and a bit annoying, even the leading lady pressures her 'little brother'. It is all-age friendly, especially with three generations included, and highlights some of the cross-generational problems that wouldn't exist if people just stopped and thought about how we make life difficult for others through thoughtless comments etc. Whilst the pretend partner plot is not original, this movie still has merit, especially the acting of Jesse Hutch (who is almost unrecognisable with his covid lockdown-locks).
  • Warning: Spoilers
    I'm not sure why other reviewers so enjoy trashing movies that are actually quite entertaining. Sure, the storyline in general is not original, but this is a romance movie, not a film competing for a Best Picture Oscar. If these reviewers are looking for completely original stories, they are looking at the wrong genre. With romances, it is in the execution--writing/dialogue, acting and direction.

    Ali Cobrin is simply wonderful in this film. She plays CALLIE, a mid-30's business owner being constantly admonished by her well-meaning but VERY annoying mother, father, and older sister because she is still single. They are always trying to set her up. She loves her family, but feels harassed by their set-ups (mostly with apparent losers).

    Because her family is throwing her a 35th birthday party soon and demanding she bring a date, she enlists the aid of a friend (WILL) that she coincidentally just met when she went out for drinks with her younger brother KYLE after the last fix-up fiasco at family dinner. (Kyle is the only family member not interested in hassling his sister about dating, coincidentally). Will is Kyle's friend, and it turns out he too is single, and NOT in any hurry to "find someone." After talking, Will agrees to pose as Callie's boyfriend for a couple of weeks. What could go wrong?

    Besides simply speaking lines, Cobrin also uses her talents of expression to convey her thoughts and feelings. This is an excellent talent and one not all actors possess, or, especially, use. Her costar Jesse Hutch (her brother's friend, WILL), is also an excellent casting choice as he has a similar talent, if not as well-developed as Cobrin's seems to be.

    Those two main stars pull this movie up by its bootstraps. Note that It isn't that the other costars are not good--they play their roles satisfactorily, but most viewers will likely find them a bit irritating at times for the reasons stated above. This is because the writers wrote their characters the way they did. It's the one negative about the movie--are any families as annoying as Callie's, constantly on a 35-year-old woman's back to marry? Likely not in real life--but of course this is a movie--NOT real life, and as such we are asked to leave our disbelief at the door (which some reviewers can't do). So yes, the family is annoying, but we understand that this attitude of the family's is required for this particular plot to work.

    I won't go into the last half hour or so of the film. I've said enough about the plot in general. Let me end by saying that Ali Cobrin impressed me mightily. She is beautiful and very talented. Playing her business partner MIA in the film is Mika Mitchell, another beautiful young lady who is very impressive. Charles Cottier plays brother KYLE and stands out as the aforementioned only family member who doesn't make Callie's life miserable. These last two add a lot to the film. Do watch Mia and Kyle in this movie, too.

    I highly recommend this film--I certainly enjoyed it.
  • Kirpianuscus16 April 2022
    The fake boyfriend is a top very familiar theme. In this case working more than decent for actors chemistry, some tender moments, for humor and reasonable cliches. Short- a dark hair Prince Charming, a young lady under pressure of family and a sort of mutual help with predictable end. So, just nice.