The good and the bads.
So before going into the good and bad list, this episode is basically the culmination and the "payoff" of all the setups and build-ups we've had throughout the previous episodes. And I think it's just fine, nothing amazing and nothing bad either.
Now the goods:
- That ending. That's all I'm gonna say about it.
- It's probably the most well-paced and exciting episode since episode 1.
- Finally seeing what the bigger picture is and what the writers are going for for this season.
- Decent dialogue between Loki and Loki.
- The intrigue and investment in this show is back with this episode
And pretty much that's about the goods about this episode I can think of without talking about the technical obvious like saying the music or the acting and the production value is good or something.
Now the bads (and mediocre - not necessarily totally bad):
- That bigger picture we finally get to know of is kind of disappointing compared to the last season.
- The payoff to the setups of episode 1 is just meh? Like I don't see why they focused so much on that particular scene as if it's very very important to the bigger picture (obviously I know it is since Loki was saved), or as if something mindblowing is gonna happen and the twist of all twists will be revealed. It's something pretty much everybody already guessed. I'm actually not sure if the writers actually meant for this scene to be a mindblowing time-travel twist or something, because if it was, it would be the lamest attempt at a time-travel twist ever. And because it seems like that particular "unsolved" mystery was resolved and doesn't look like there's much more to it, I don't understand why they lingered on that scene and made it seem like a bigger thing than it actually is. Dark's time travel twists compared to this show's is like Shakespeare vs an 8-grader writing for his storytelling class.
- The cowards not actually showing anything from that Dox scene. I understand them not showing it obviously, and didn't have a problem with the first time. But when they show it multiple times and showing people's reaction to it, I expect them to at least show the dripping maybe? Like how can they not even show two drops of blood in this show? Marvel is already past all the PG stuff and has shown that they're not really scared of showing blood anymore. So why not show that and then do the match cut to that machine they clearly wanted to do? A match cut doesn't really work if you're too afraid to show literally nothing of the first scene and only do the sound and leave it to the audience's imagination. Like I said, I actually like that they did not show it at first and used sound design instead, but when they do it multiple times and do a half match cut, it's kinda lame. This is just a nitpick though, not really something that made the episode worse or anything or to affect my rating and enjoyment of it.
- Speaking of the Dox scene. How much more emotional and great would this scene have been if Dox actually had a characterization is this season more than the one-dimensional treatment they gave her? Like I don't understand how it worked in season 1, but here it seems like everything is rushed and we don't get that much characterization from these characters? Like you can see the potential of these plot points becoming some of the most iconic, shocking, or even heartbreaking scenes in TV history even. But when your season has only 6 episodes and you dedicate your entire 3rd episode to a rather dull interrogation instead of developing side characters, your audience isn't really gonna connect emotionally with them when you want them. Like this would've been one of the best scenes of any show if that show had more episodes per season and these characters were actually introduced and developed nicely in the first season. But nope, your audience isn't really gonna care it much.
So these are most of my complaints which some of them are not even exclusive to this episode and are mostly the result of the whole storyline of this season and what the writers tried to do. Obviously, the ending is really great and even I didn't even see it coming, and I'm glad that we are back to the season 1 feel of not knowing what's gonna happen next. But I guess I don't really think this season's storyline is even near as interesting and mysterious as the first.
Overall, this is by far the best episode of the season so far and I knew they had to do something to make this interesting again, just like season 1's scene of Loki getting pruned, and they actually did it. Most of my complaints above are about the season as a whole and not particularly this episode. But still, I think the payoff to the first episode's setup is kinda lame and not as shocking as the writers might have thought would be. And if it wasn't their intention for it to be a twist or a mindblowing revelation, I'm not sure why they focused on it so much and took their sweet time with it.
And while the story of this season isn't as good or intriguing as the first's, it's gonna be a bigger disappointment if we see again that this season's events have zero impact on the MCU as a whole. Also, the lack of variants of anybody is kinda concerning. They really took their time with this TVA and Loom stuff and took 66% of the season without much happening until now. I just hope whatever revelation they do in the next two episodes is worth it and is bigger and greater than just Ravonna wanting to take control of TVA (=lame).