'Big' Pauley (103 episodes, 2009-2016)
Vinny 'Two Times' (103 episodes, 2009-2016)
Angela Scozzio / Angela Scozzio Carducci / Vinny's Girl (38 episodes, 2009-2016)
Special Agent Venessa Fitch / Vensessa Fitch / Venessa Fitch / FBI Agent Vensessa Fitch (35 episodes, 2010-2016)
Captain Guiness O'Hara (20 episodes, 2012-2016)
Tina Toledo / Trivia Girl / Sasha Ray / Trivia Girl Tina Toledo (17 episodes, 2009-2016)
Donald P. Smith / Boris / Boris Stroganoff (16 episodes, 2009-2016)
Dottie DeVille (16 episodes, 2014-2016)
Scarlett Yohansson / Scarlett 'Salino' Yohansson / Scarlott Yohansson (15 episodes, 2010-2013)
Astoria Nored (12 episodes, 2012-2013)
Trivia Girl / Weather Girl (11 episodes, 2009-2010)
Benny Blanco (10 episodes, 2012-2015)
Antonio Critelli / Antonio / Bartender (10 episodes, 2009-2010)
Stan Spielberg (9 episodes, 2009-2013)
Detective Mary Matthews (9 episodes, 2015-2016)
Crystall Glass (8 episodes, 2010-2011)
Trivia Girl / Weather Girl (5 episodes, 2009)
Esther Jones (5 episodes, 2015-2016)
Anna Marie Grace (5 episodes, 2010-2013)
Pepper Anderson (5 episodes, 2014-2016)
Nelle Berry (5 episodes, 2012-2013)
Fast Freddy Marcos (4 episodes, 2015-2016)
Candi 'Cupcakes' Kassinski (4 episodes, 2015)
Detective Malonie (4 episodes, 2010-2012)
Momma Scozzio (4 episodes, 2012-2015)
Roxana Alexander / Natalie Treasure (4 episodes, 2014-2015)
Dmitriy Peklovich / Gus / Gus Loans / Officer Gus Loans (4 episodes, 2010-2015)
Papa Scozzio (4 episodes, 2012-2015)
Sarah Sugarlumps / Bar Patron / Sarah 1st AD (4 episodes, 2009-2011)
Tifffany Glass / Officer Sinde Savings / Tiffany Glass (3 episodes, 2011)
Trivia Girl Angel Aphroditie (3 episodes, 2010)
Natasha Fatale (3 episodes, 2014)
Dr. Gaylord Crane (3 episodes, 2015-2016)
Shotgun Sammy / Camera Operator (3 episodes, 2009-2011)
Charlie 'Carlito' Brigante (2 episodes, 2012-2013)
Fredrick / Tommy 'Two Toes' (2 episodes, 2010-2011)
Brook Waters (2 episodes, 2013)
Johnny Ringo (2 episodes, 2015-2016)
Neko Danucci / Neko Danuchie (2 episodes, 2010-2011)
President Barack Obama (2 episodes, 2016)
Secert Service Agent Frank Horrigan / Secret Service Agent Frank Horrigan (2 episodes, 2016)
Pauley's Girl (1 episode, 2009)
Carlton Banks (1 episode, 2015)
Nikki Fox (1 episode, 2012)
MaryLee Comgetme (1 episode, 2010)
Kandi Kane (1 episode, 2012)
Karolyn Monrow (1 episode, 2012)
Valerie Flame (1 episode, 2014)
Ruby Ridge (1 episode, 2014)
Myra Banks (1 episode, 2014)
Sarah Lee (1 episode, 2014)
Melody Strong (1 episode, 2015)
Lucy Diamonds (1 episode, 2015)
Leslie Peterson (1 episode, 2009)
Make-Up Man (1 episode, 2009)
Dumpster Guy (1 episode, 2009)
Younger Bar Guy (1 episode, 2009)
Cue Card Man (1 episode, 2009)
Restaurant Patron (1 episode, 2009)
Restaurant Waiter (1 episode, 2009)