Shawn Spencer (as James Roday)
Burton Guster
Carlton Lassiter
Juliet O'Hara
Karen Vick (credit only)
Henry Spencer
Mel Hornsby
Wade Boggs
Neil Stillman
Izzy Jackson
Young Shawn
Cal Eason
Coroner Woody Strode
Rodriguez
Ricky Fletcher
Security Cheryl
Colt / Second Baseman
Third Baseman
Grady Barrett
Rodriguez's Wife (as Alycia Purrott)
Play by Play Announcer
Trashy Girl (as Chelsey Marie Reist)
Hot Local
Flash Back Play by Play Announcer
Rogue Crowd Member
Baseball Game Audience (uncredited)
Baseball Wife (uncredited)