Kate Burkholder
John Tomasetti
Lucas Holst
Jacob Burkholder
Glock Nichols
T.J. Banks
Mona
Sarah Burkholder
Nathan Detrick
Chuck 'Skid' Skidmore
Lieutenant Anderson
Doc Coblenz
Mayor Auggie Brock
Daniel Lapp
Mr. Waring
Ezra Ausberger
Bonnie Ausberger
Mother Burkholder
Father Burkholder (as W.J. Matheson)
Dwayne Starkey
Reporter
Cori Srinvisson (as Anna Nadtotchi)
Stutz
Young Kate Burkholder
Young Jacob
Girl
Boy
Townsperson
Amish Bishop
Wagon driver
Naomi Huyard
Amanda Brock (uncredited)