Mary (as Alycia Debnam Carey)
Jacob Brown
Trevor
Ruth
Sarah
Sheriff Stevens
Rebekah
Elder Beacon
Elder Stone
Abby
Hannah
Thomas
Ruth's Dad
Sarah's mother
Midwife
Ruth's Mom
Tobias Maker (as Robin Dale Robertson)
Midwife #2
Doctor
Susan
Amish Villager
Hannah's Dad
Frank
Elder
Villager
Sherriff's Deputy
Hannah's Mom
Town Local
Catherine
Town Elder
Village elder
Pedestrian pushing baby stroller
Village Elder
Deputy Waldrop
Party Goer
Raver
Midwife (as Kathy Walton Pulley)
Drunk Party Goer
Amish Villager (uncredited)
Amish Villiager (uncredited)
Townsperson (uncredited)
Villager (uncredited)