Satan (42 episodes, 2013-2019)
Gary (42 episodes, 2013-2019)
Claude (29 episodes, 2013-2019)
Dizzay (28 episodes, 2013-2019)
Benji (27 episodes, 2013-2019)
Lucas / Troy (24 episodes, 2013-2019)
Eddie Pepitone (23 episodes, 2013-2019)
William the Demon (15 episodes, 2013-2019)
Demon Bob / Tortured Soul Bob (11 episodes, 2015-2017)
Ben the Demon (9 episodes, 2016-2019)
Ted the Demon (6 episodes, 2015-2016)
Tortured Soul / Shane the Tortured / Tortured soul (5 episodes, 2013-2015)
V.C. the Demon (5 episodes, 2015-2016)
Krampus / Self (5 episodes, 2015-2019)
Kamal (4 episodes, 2013-2016)
Demon Johnny (4 episodes, 2018-2019)
Priest (4 episodes, 2013-2019)
Geoff (3 episodes, 2015)
Keith the Tortured (3 episodes, 2017-2019)
Young Wife (3 episodes, 2013-2015)
(3 episodes, 2015-2016)
Stitches MacKillinghim / Vomitting Necronomicon (3 episodes, 2015-2019)
Gary's Mom (3 episodes, 2013-2015)
Hockey Shotgun Guy / Hockey Shotgun Guy (2013) (2 episodes, 2013-2019)
Christian / Mailman (2 episodes, 2015-2016)
Torture Consultant (2 episodes, 2016-2019)
Cerberus (2 episodes, 2015-2019)
Principal (2 episodes, 2013-2019)
Demon Teacher (2 episodes, 2015)
Lucas' Nana (2 episodes, 2013-2019)
Old Man (2 episodes, 2013-2015)
Young Husband (2 episodes, 2013)
Coach / Youth Minister (2 episodes, 2013-2019)
Big N' Wide (2 episodes, 2015-2018)
Mike the Demon (2 episodes, 2015-2016)
Homeless Man (2 episodes, 2013)
Claudius the Angel (2 episodes, 2015-2019)
Gumphamickel / Gumphanickel (2 episodes, 2015)
Krampus / Self (2 episodes, 2017-2019)
Preacher (1 episode, 2015)
Deputy Sheriff (2 episodes, 2013)
Judge / Kip the Golfer (2 episodes, 2015-2019)
Cerberus (Puppet) / Psyklone (Puppet) (2 episodes, 2015)
Angela (Still Photos) / Screaming Girl (1 episode, 2016)
Tiffany (1 episode, 2013)
Moon Rabbit (1 episode, 2013)
Cortez Cruz (1 episode, 2013)
Angel (1 episode, 2015)
Wendy (1 episode, 2015)
Modok (1 episode, 2015)
Madison (1 episode, 2015)
(1 episode, 2015)
Jett Copperhead (1 episode, 2015)
(1 episode, 2016)
Josef Mengele (1 episode, 2017)
Goody Goody (1 episode, 2018)
War (1 episode, 2019)
Gail Dugan (1 episode, 2019)
Milk & Honey Rep (1 episode, 2019)
Self (1 episode, 2019)
Amy (1 episode, 2019)
Spencer (1 episode, 2013)
Alex (1 episode, 2013)
Denise (1 episode, 2013)
The Thin Twins (1 episode, 2015)
Wolfgang Ragekiss (1 episode, 2015)
Joanna (1 episode, 2015)
Cleaning Woman (1 episode, 2015)
Eric (1 episode, 2016)
Dustin Diamond (1 episode, 2017)
Dr. Paul NickGibbion (1 episode, 2017)
Todd (1 episode, 2017)
Carl Dugan (1 episode, 2019)
Joey Fatone (1 episode, 2019)
Archie Shoemaker (1 episode, 2019)
Pestilence (1 episode, 2019)
Psyklone (1 episode, 2015)
Jett's Wife (1 episode, 2015)
Dean (1 episode, 2015)
Kip (1 episode, 2016)
Jenny (1 episode, 2017)
Adolf Hitler / Cody St. Clair (1 episode, 2017)
Anton McDuffy (1 episode, 2019)
Lip Licker (1 episode, 2019)
Senator's Receptionist (1 episode, 2013)
Young Woman (1 episode, 2013)
Josh (1 episode, 2013)
Tortured #2 (1 episode, 2013)
(1 episode, 2013)
Scott (1 episode, 2015)
Judge (1 episode, 2015)
Ethan Rakestraw (1 episode, 2015)
Dr. Mengele (1 episode, 2016)
(1 episode, 2017)
Hazim (1 episode, 2017)
Handsome Guy (1 episode, 2017)
(1 episode, 2019)
Death (1 episode, 2019)
Tina (1 episode, 2013)
Jeff Smith (1 episode, 2013)
Screaming Man (1 episode, 2013)
Baseball Security (1 episode, 2013)
Erick (1 episode, 2015)
North Dakota (1 episode, 2015)
Abutu (1 episode, 2015)
Larry (1 episode, 2017)
Becky (1 episode, 2017)
Foster (1 episode, 2019)
Ashley (1 episode, 2019)
Pit Boss (1 episode, 2019)
Lunch Lady (1 episode, 2019)
Dr. Ashby (1 episode, 2019)
Sports Interviewer (1 episode, 2013)
Chorus Student #1 (1 episode, 2013)
Jonas (1 episode, 2015)
Librarian (1 episode, 2015)
Pregnant Woman (1 episode, 2015)
Cheryl (1 episode, 2016)
Dad (1 episode, 2017)
Sitcom Mom (1 episode, 2017)
Famine (1 episode, 2019)
Lexi (1 episode, 2019)
Stephen (1 episode, 2019)
Gerald (1 episode, 2019)
OMGouija Grandma (1 episode, 2019)
Barack Obama (1 episode, 2019)
Hippie Drummer (1 episode, 2013)
Bertha (1 episode, 2015)
Ice Cream Man (1 episode, 2015)
Tennis Player (1 episode, 2017)
Lee (1 episode, 2017)
Sitcom Kid (1 episode, 2017)
Angel (1 episode, 2018)
Muscular Angel (1 episode, 2019)
Producer (1 episode, 2019)
Amy's Dad (1 episode, 2019)
Jimmy (1 episode, 2019)
Stephen's Barbara (1 episode, 2019)
Lance (1 episode, 2013)
Husband (1 episode, 2015)
Church Lady (1 episode, 2015)
Regan (1 episode, 2017)
Inmate (1 episode, 2017)
Settler (1 episode, 2017)
Escape Room Manager (1 episode, 2019)
Bill Frood the Science Dude (1 episode, 2019)
Miranda (1 episode, 2019)
Beautiful Woman (1 episode, 2019)
Kyle (1 episode, 2013)
Park Woman (1 episode, 2015)
Sheila (1 episode, 2015)
Beefy Backgammon (1 episode, 2019)
OMGouija Girl (1 episode, 2019)
Emma (1 episode, 2015)
Cop (1 episode, 2019)
Justin (1 episode, 2013)
Hester (1 episode, 2015)
Benny Hill Guy (1 episode, 2015)
Bar Woman #3 (1 episode, 2015)
Gary's Dad (1 episode, 2016)
Amy's Mom (1 episode, 2019)
Anna (1 episode, 2015)
Kody (1 episode, 2019)
Chinese Worker 1 (1 episode, 2015)
Chinese Worker 2 (1 episode, 2015)
Leftover Salmon (1 episode, 2013)
Chinese Foreman (1 episode, 2015)
Chorus Student #2 (1 episode, 2013)
Security Guard (1 episode, 2013)
Farmer (1 episode, 2013)
Tortured soul (1 episode, 2013)
Senator's Son (1 episode, 2013)
Security Gaurd (1 episode, 2013)
Twerking Demon (1 episode, 2013)
Forensics Lab Technician (1 episode, 2013)
Woman at Fridge (1 episode, 2015)
Possessed Mormon Boy (1 episode, 2015)
Dakota (1 episode, 2015)
80s A&R Guy (1 episode, 2015)
Little Santa Girl (1 episode, 2015)
Woman In Bar (1 episode, 2015)
Doctor (1 episode, 2016)
Milk and Honey Girl (1 episode, 2019)
Wrestler (1 episode, 2019)
Cop #2 (1 episode, 2019)
Bald Succubus (1 episode, 2019)
Bartender (1 episode, 2019)
Youth Group Member (1 episode, 2019)
OMGouija Dad (1 episode, 2019)
Gary Bunda's Feet (1 episode, 2019)
Senator's Daughter (uncredited) (1 episode, 2013)
Drum Circle (uncredited) (1 episode, 2013)
Demon Bartender (uncredited) (1 episode, 2016)
Bar Patron (uncredited) (1 episode, 2017)
Restaurant Parent (uncredited) (1 episode, 2019)
Producer (uncredited) (1 episode, 2019)