Detective Benton / Ben / Bert / Charles Worthman / Cop / Don / Dr. Martel / Ghost / High Priest Mortron / James Lillard / Jerry / Larry / Mr. Grundy / Steve Misch (15 episodes, 2014-2018)
Detective D'Angelo / Jennifer / Christine / Deanna / Denise / Diana / Kayla / Lisette Worthman / Miss Renee / Sheila / Trudy Misch / Woman (14 episodes, 2014-2016)
Katie Stotts / Serena Diego (2 episodes, 2015-2018)
Elizabeth McCollum / Heather (2 episodes, 2015-2018)
Lamar (1 episode, 2014)
Pete (1 episode, 2014)
Suzanne (1 episode, 2014)
Cult Member #1 (1 episode, 2014)
Cult Member #2 (1 episode, 2014)
Cult Member #3 (1 episode, 2014)
Rick (1 episode, 2014)
Grace (1 episode, 2015)
Hairstylist (1 episode, 2015)
Charmane (1 episode, 2015)
Frank Blunden (1 episode, 2015)
Donna (1 episode, 2015)
Ricky (1 episode, 2015)
Classy Lady (1 episode, 2015)
Creep (1 episode, 2015)
Janet (1 episode, 2015)
Design Specialist (1 episode, 2015)
Moviegoer (1 episode, 2015)
Wyatt (1 episode, 2015)
Candy (1 episode, 2016)
John (1 episode, 2016)
Mark Turner (1 episode, 2018)
Townsperson (1 episode, 2018)
Katie's Mom (1 episode, 2018)