Beatrice Prescott
Theresa Portinari
Tippy Sloane Prescott
Caesare
Young Beatrice
13-year-old Beatrice
13-year-old Leighton
Elmo Heinie
Leighton Hathaway
Magiq
Dr. Hyman Kaplan
Father O'Malley
Lady Gaga
Older Dante
Guy in Bathroom
Narrator (voice)
Neil Durkman
Officer Leslie Shaunessy
Security Guard
Wedding Guest
Older Beatrice
Young Dante
Sergio Portinari