Fawn Harriman
Kyle Blaker
Matteus 'Matt' Darnell
Wendy Shardlow
Indira 'Indy' Divani
Jevan Blaker
Elliot Saunders
Celia Nightingale
Victor Stewart
Rev. Simon Randall
Liz Randall
Wayne Fletcher
Karen
Dorothy Felix
Ed Clayton
Frank Harriman
Jean Harriman
Tanya Hernández / Amityville Villager
Amityville Librarian
Diner Waiter
Motel Owner
Bookstore Clerk
Scary Lady / Amityville Villager
Mayor's Heavy
Dannemora Security
Dannemora School Pupil
Dannemora School Pupil / Amityville Villager (as Jayden Lowe)
Dannemora School Pupil (as Kira Paterson)
Dannemora School Pupil / Amityville Villager (as Jordan Shand)
Amityville Roxy Audience
Amityville Roxy Audience / Amityville Villager
Amityville Villager
Additional Cast