Narrator (16 episodes, 2016-2017)
NYPD Officer / NYPD officer / Police Officer (3 episodes, 2016)
Kansas City Cop / Jack Litman's Assistant / Lawyer (3 episodes, 2016)
Cosmo Fallarino / Uniform Officer #1 / Zipperz Male 1 (3 episodes, 2017)
Cheerleader / Jo Musel Parr (2 episodes, 2016-2017)
Laney Jacobs / Lanie Jacobs (2 episodes, 2017)
Claudia Pikul (2 episodes, 2016)
Self (2 episodes, 2016)
Bobby Ferrara (2 episodes, 2017)
Patricia Pomeroy (2 episodes, 2017)
Robyn Arnold (2 episodes, 2017)
Self (2 episodes, 2017)
Bobby Joe Fabian / Roy Radin (2 episodes, 2017)
Joey Bennett (1 episode, 2016)
Betty Gore (1 episode, 2017)
Kurt Rouse (1 episode, 2017)
Sarah Rairdon (1 episode, 2017)
Helen Mintiks (1 episode, 2017)
Candy Montgomery (1 episode, 2017)
Diane Weaver (1 episode, 2017)
Kirk Buckner (1 episode, 2016)
Matthew Stuart (1 episode, 2016)
Timothy Buckner (1 episode, 2016)
NYPD Officer (1 episode, 2016)
(1 episode, 2016)
Police Officer (1 episode, 2016)
Alex Arnold (1 episode, 2016)
Deputy #2 (1 episode, 2016)
Steve Buckner (1 episode, 2016)
Sheriff Rainey (1 episode, 2016)
Detective Miller Thomas (1 episode, 2016)
Willie Bennett (1 episode, 2016)
Diane Pikul (1 episode, 2016)
Don Pierce (1 episode, 2016)
Detective (1 episode, 2016)
Pete Edlund (1 episode, 2016)
Julie (1 episode, 2016)
Cheerleader (1 episode, 2016)
Jennifer's Preppy Friend (1 episode, 2016)
Robert Chambers (1 episode, 2016)
Bartender (1 episode, 2016)
Linda Fairstein (1 episode, 2016)
Reporter (1 episode, 2016)
FBI Agent Bob Gast (1 episode, 2016)
Arthur Costas (1 episode, 2016)
Linda Culbertson (1 episode, 2016)
Bernadette Protti (1 episode, 2016)
Dennis Buckner (1 episode, 2016)
Preppy Friend (1 episode, 2016)
Bruce Rouse (1 episode, 2017)
CSI Investigator (1 episode, 2017)
Student (1 episode, 2017)
Female Classmate 1 (1 episode, 2017)
Laura Schultz (1 episode, 2017)
Marilyn (1 episode, 2017)
SGT Dave Ostertag (1 episode, 2017)
Church Parishioner (1 episode, 2017)
Thomas Drescher (1 episode, 2017)
Step-brother (1 episode, 2017)
Marcia Clark (1 episode, 2017)
Hiker (1 episode, 2017)
Craig Crimmins (1 episode, 2017)
Valery Panov (1 episode, 2017)
Gary Santisario (1 episode, 2017)
Dan Reid (1 episode, 2017)
Debra Gere (1 episode, 2017)
Robert Bardo (1 episode, 2017)
Matthew Solomon (1 episode, 2017)
Ryan (1 episode, 2017)
Brad Silberling (1 episode, 2017)
Robin Rouse (1 episode, 2017)
CSI / FBI agent (1 episode, 2017)
Female Neighbor (1 episode, 2017)
(1 episode, 2017)
Laura Cutler (1 episode, 2017)
Janis (1 episode, 2017)
Club Bouncer (1 episode, 2017)
Police Officer (1 episode, 2017)
Vince Donahue (1 episode, 2017)
Robin's friend (1 episode, 2017)
Kirksey Nix (1 episode, 2017)
Peter Halat (1 episode, 2017)
Billy (1 episode, 2017)
Pawn Shop Owner (1 episode, 2017)
Pretty Blonde (1 episode, 2017)
Charles St. Denis (1 episode, 2017)
Allan Gore (1 episode, 2017)
Robins Friend (1 episode, 2017)
William Rider (1 episode, 2017)
Detective (1 episode, 2017)
CSI (1 episode, 2017)
Female Classmate 2 (1 episode, 2017)
Mike Gillich (1 episode, 2017)
Traci Graham (1 episode, 2017)
Ron Pomeroy (1 episode, 2017)
Dominick Giorgio (1 episode, 2017)
Uniformed Officer 1 (1 episode, 2017)
Ventriloquist (1 episode, 2017)
Lisa Solomon (1 episode, 2017)
Self (1 episode, 2017)
Younger sister (1 episode, 2017)
Demond Wilson (1 episode, 2017)
Zipperz Male 3 (1 episode, 2017)
Det. Jerry Giorgio (1 episode, 2017)
Det. Sherbrooke (1 episode, 2017)
Uncle (1 episode, 2017)
Mary Laney (1 episode, 2017)
Female Classmate 3 (1 episode, 2017)
Sue Cameron (1 episode, 2017)
Carol Stuart (unknown episodes)
Charles Stuart (unknown episodes)
Pastor (uncredited) (1 episode, 2017)
Thomas Holcomb (uncredited) (1 episode, 2017)
Bobby (uncredited) (1 episode, 2017)