Mrs. Foxworth
Gatekeeper
Jerry
Angelina
Nina
Yvonne
James Bennett Foxworth
Anthony
Martin Thomas
Aunt Maggie
Otto (as a different name)
Herb
Elf
Molly Bennett Foxworth
Ravin Bennett Foxworth
Mrs. Hawkins
Natasha Hipsteiner
Hector
Joseph
Santa Claus
Lia
Lucille
Deacon Scott
Lois
Beth Anne
Nathan Winslow
Laura Winslow (as Natalie Pack)
Mike Davenport
Mr. Turner
Bakery Santa (as Randall Malone)
Apples Customer
Driver
Voice of God (voice)