Lily
Em
Sarah
Bex
Principal Turrell
Diamond
Nick Mathers
Grace
Johnny
Mark
Mayor Bartlett
Reagan
Mason
Nance
Officer Richter
Marty
Langley
Eric
Rose Mathers (as Susie Misner)
Rebecca Coulson
Lawrence
Chief Patterson
Donny
Officer Daniels
Alexis Turrell
Allie
Mom in Supermarket
Passenger
Some Guy
Carlie
Margie
Diamond's Mom
FBI Agent Richard Vernon
Stone-Faced Teen (as a different name)
Grace's Father
Guy in Street
Marty's Father
Dave a.k.a. Rando Dude
Tank Top (as Gabriel O. McCulloch)
Teammate 1 (as Jacob A. Brown)
Teammate 2
Salem Resident 1
Superintendent Lisa Sanders
Salem High Girl
Snap Back (as TC Carter)
Salem Resident 2
Mrs. Bartlett (as Elizabeth Elkins)
Woman in House
Masked Person (uncredited)
Angry Mob (uncredited)
Mob Patron (uncredited)
A / V Club Student (uncredited)
Masked Mob (uncredited)
Football Player (uncredited)
Party Goer (uncredited)
Student (uncredited)
Nikki (uncredited)
Masked Townsperson (uncredited)
Citizen (uncredited)
Cheerleader (uncredited)
Masked Gunman (uncredited)
Rebellious Neighbor (uncredited)
Masked Neighbor / Diamond Body Double (uncredited)
Masked Man (uncredited)
Red Hat Football Player (uncredited)