Scott (32 episodes, 2018-2024)
Jim (24 episodes, 2019-2024)
James (15 episodes, 2021-2024)
Calista (14 episodes, 2018-2022)
BJ (14 episodes, 2018-2023)
Whitney (10 episodes, 2018-2022)
Brian (9 episodes, 2019-2024)
Roderick (8 episodes, 2020-2023)
Jamila (6 episodes, 2019-2022)
Mary-Kate (6 episodes, 2021-2024)
Vanessa (5 episodes, 2018-2022)
The Third One (5 episodes, 2022-2024)
Calvin (5 episodes, 2022-2024)
Mack (4 episodes, 2018)
Ashley (4 episodes, 2021-2024)
Mack / Santa Chuck (4 episodes, 2022)
Erin (3 episodes, 2019-2022)
Hooded Figure / Ted (2 episodes, 2024)
Christopher (2 episodes, 2024)
Elizabeth (2 episodes, 2022)
Homeowner (1 episode, 2018)
Kelly (1 episode, 2024)
Photographer (1 episode, 2023)