Narrator (17 episodes, 2018-2020)
Amy Mihaljevic (3 episodes, 2018)
Self - Amy's Father (3 episodes, 2018)
Self - Amy's Brother (3 episodes, 2018)
Self - Family Friend (3 episodes, 2018)
Self - Amy's Friend (3 episodes, 2018)
Police officer 1 / Suspect (1 episode, 2018-2020)
Self - True Crime Garage Host (2 episodes, 2018)
Self - Amy's Friend (2 episodes, 2018)
Detective Renner (1 episode, 2018)
Leslie Williams (1 episode, 2020)
Mark Christie (1 episode, 2020)
Joan Giambra (1 episode, 2019)
Jim O'Brien (1 episode, 2020)
Father Gerald Robinson (1 episode, 2020)
Self - Author (1 episode, 2018)
Mark Mihaljevic (1 episode, 2018)
State Police (1 episode, 2018)
Perpetrator (1 episode, 2018)
Self - FBI (1 episode, 2018)
Richard Alan Folbert (1 episode, 2018)
Self - Mark's Step-Son (1 episode, 2018)
Detective Jim Tompkins (1 episode, 2018)
Self - True Crime Reporter (1 episode, 2018)
Self - Local Resident (1 episode, 2018)
Jason Mihaljevic (1 episode, 2018)
Self - Kristy's Mother (1 episode, 2018)
Self - Chief of Police (1 episode, 2018)
Self - Kristy's Brother (1 episode, 2018)
Self - Reporter (1 episode, 2018)
Self - Police (1 episode, 2018)
Hernandez Warren (1 episode, 2019)
Don (1 episode, 2019)
Detective Martin (1 episode, 2019)
Bar Patron (1 episode, 2019)
Raymond (1 episode, 2019)
Uniformed officer (1 episode, 2019)
Dave Perry (1 episode, 2019)
Jane (1 episode, 2019)
Self - Private Investigator (1 episode, 2019)
Det. Dennis Delano (1 episode, 2019)
Self - Debbie's Friend (1 episode, 2019)
Self - Debbie's Mother (1 episode, 2019)
Self - Debbie's Sister (1 episode, 2019)
Self - Detective (1 episode, 2019)
Detective (1 episode, 2019)
Jamie Osborne (1 episode, 2020)
Jane Holtsclaw (1 episode, 2020)
David (1 episode, 2020)
Dan Deeter (1 episode, 2020)
Cop (1 episode, 2020)
Barry Barnett (1 episode, 2020)
Detective Graham (1 episode, 2020)
Dondi Craig (1 episode, 2020)
Keith Sibble (1 episode, 2020)
Melissa (1 episode, 2020)
George (1 episode, 2020)
Matthew Adler (1 episode, 2020)
Young Andy Gustafson (1 episode, 2020)
Duncan (1 episode, 2020)
Eddie (1 episode, 2020)
Art Ludwig (1 episode, 2020)
Detective Jay Gast (1 episode, 2020)
Mike Head (1 episode, 2020)
CSI Crime Scene Photographer (1 episode, 2020)
Detective McDonough (1 episode, 2020)
Dan Paden (1 episode, 2020)
Wanda Musk (1 episode, 2020)
Patricia Woodruff (1 episode, 2020)
Nurse (1 episode, 2020)
Detective Washington Lacey (1 episode, 2020)
Boyfriend (1 episode, 2020)
Self - Witness (1 episode, 2020)
Aaron riggins (1 episode, 2020)
David Alexander Snow (1 episode, 2020)
Clair Sibble (1 episode, 2020)
Elderly Appleton (1 episode, 2020)
Young Nun (1 episode, 2020)
Detective (1 episode, 2020)
FBI agent (1 episode, 2020)
Hero Cop (1 episode, 2020)
Judy Tosh (1 episode, 2020)
Rosie Davenport (1 episode, 2020)
Ian Blackburn (1 episode, 2020)
Girl in Ice Cream Palour / Trick Or Treater (uncredited) (2 episodes, 2020)
Volunteer (uncredited) (1 episode, 2018)
Cindy (uncredited) (1 episode, 2020)