Very Good I'll be the first to admit that I am a sucker for military dramas. I am also a very big Denzel Washington fan. Thus, for me anyway, this movie had it all. The acting was superb across the board. Everyone both looked and acted perfectly for the part. Matt Damon lost about 40 pounds to look appropriately emaciated and strung out for the part. Anyway, I guess I'm trying to say that I do not agree with the other (previous) reviews of this film. Yes, the story ended predictably, but shat else do you expect from a story of redemption? failure? Nat Serling is a character we want to see overcome his demons, and he does. This does not make the movie a cliche. It is not the destination that counts, it is the journey that takes us there. The unfolding of the various stories of the drama of Karen Walden's demise is both intriguing and gripping. I can honestly say that when the truth is finally revealed that my jaw dropped, and that I walked out of the theater in tears. (small, macho tears, but tears none the less) My only bitch, other than a small tech goof, is that James Horner's soundtrack is very predictable by the numbers and gave me no joy, but then I'm fussy about soundtracks. As is obvious by my over-long comment, this is a great movie and a must see for any Meg Ryan or Denzel Washington fan, or for lovers of military flicks in general.