Liked it, entertained me. I would have done a few things different. My basis for rating any movie is how I feel in the end. I don't listen to reviews of others, just base it off of my expectations and understanding going in, but my biggest driver is how I feel when its over. Did my time go fast and with Logan, it went really fast. I loved it and it entertained me.
All the characters are great! Dafne Keen is awesome X-23 times infinity! She does it perfectly.
Now, I would have done a few things different.
1. I would have given more information on what happened to mutants and the status of what is happening to Logan. Is he sick...is he terminal....is he ready to die....is he lonely....does he miss the old days. Something, I just needed a little more.
2. More information about the comic books. Who is writing them and are they secretly being written by a mutant that tells the future or is trying to communicate to mutants and tells the future? Are they secret code to mutants?
3. All the F bombs weren't needed. It changed the characters from past movies. I applaud them for not thinking that Logan had to have a romantic interest because that gets so predictable. It wouldn't have fit in at Logan's stage in his life, I don't think he would have much feelings in that area anymore as he is cold and tired of it all. The extra gore wasn't needed either. No point in it, just didn't fit in those scenes.
4. I felt bad for the farming family. Wow...thanks a lot Charles! They should have known better than to stay there. Not that I need the happy ending, but I would have thought Logan, Charles and the girl should have saved them.
5. The kid mutants were too scared. They should have been more barbaric in the end. If the movie wanted gore, that was the time to bring it in. The kids were just like any other kids running from the bogey man and it was like they didn't know their own powers.
6. And did I miss something, but what was up with the robot arms?