Hugh's Voyage Into North London Greatly enjoyed About a Boy, even more than (gasp) the book. There's nothing like Nick Hornby to give you a good time at the old cinny, but with a healthy dollop of fibre so you know that it's also good for you.
They definitely have to give out Oscars for performances like Hugh Grant's. Unfortunately, "light comedy/drama" doesn't cut it with the Academy. To date, Colin Firth and John Cusack have taken shots at Nick's classic "stunted emotional man trying to connect to real life without props (Pop, Arsenal, etc.)" but Hugh's is the best. Toni Collette also did extremely well, making a role that could have been laughable have real resonance by the end.
I think I enjoyed the film so much because, paradoxically, I didn't connect to the book the way I did to Fever Pitch and High Fidelity. I just took it as a movie, rather than as an adapted version of something very close to my heart. The only downside? It lost half a point for the "guitar at school" scene, which seemed to be pasted into the screenplay to give Will a chance to absorb humiliation on behalf of Marcus. But this is worthy of a high recommendation. Much more than a Hugh Grant romantic comedy chickflick.