Good premise, very mediocre show, not Lovecraft I forget exactly when I realized that Lovecraft Country was not a great show. Perhaps it was when magic entered into the plot. Or maybe, it was when characters started straight-facing about "The Book of names" and chanting spells at each other. Or could it be when the writers trotted out subtle masterpieces of dialog such as, "I didn't need money, whiteness is its own currency." Ugh, what a shame. For although Lovecraft Country could have been great, it instead opted to be a cliched mess without a clear voice or message.
Now that's not to say that Lovecraft Country is terrible. I would even venture that, if you go in with the right mindset, you can enjoy it. But I wanted Lovecraft Country to have some teeth, I wanted it to bring us an interesting perspective on race in America. Horror, especially Lovecraftian horror, seems like the perfect way to do that. For say what you will about Lovecraft as a person, the man created a unique style of horror that remains immensely effective to this day. His stories are usually slow burns with unknown dreads lurking in the shadows. Often the most horrifying bits are what you don't see. The potential parallels to racism in America are clear. By invoking Lovecraft's name, the show leads you to believe it's going to pull off a grand ol' coup by using Lovecraft's own style to show the horrors of racism. Racism that he very much practiced. Yet this potential is almost completely wasted.
Simply put, Lovecraft Country show is not Lovecraftian. It borrows a few names and high level concepts from Lovecraft, but that's it. It's not even its own variety of pulp. If anything, Lovecraft Country reminds me more of a show you'd see on the CW.
Which, again, fine! A bit of false advertising IMO but whatever. Yet even if you take Lovecraft Country as its own distinct work, it's just not great TV. The larger series plot is an absolute mess, the messaging is muddled, and the writing ranges from passable to laughably bad. It's a guilty pleasure type of show at best, sort of like True Blood was.
Again though, it's not like I hated it. I liked the characters for instance, especially the core family group. A few podcasts and reviews I've heard also note that the show features characters who you don't often see on the screen. Such as having a Black girl who likes astronomy. Such as opening with a Black man reading a book. I mean God that's a depressing low bar for representation when you think about it, but the real sad part is that it's true! And while these characters suffer from some major writing issues, at least they are properly fleshed out and feel like unique humans in their own right. It's not revolutionary but a good step towards what normal should be.
But oh man, let me tell you: these characters are saddled with some amazingly bad dialog! Characters often just state what they are feeling and why. Sometimes a character will straight up tell you what the writer wants you to take away from a scene, such as the whole, "I don't need money ..." bit. That line made me cringe so hard that I fell off my couch. Writing like this insults the audience's intelligence. Maybe some old white dudes need blunt message like this, but the rest of us would have been far better off with more showing and far less telling.
And then there's the season plot. I'll be honest here: I had no clue why anyone was doing anything or what was going on a good deal of the time. Why do they need this magical book? Why is their family special? And why is there magic in the first place? I'm sure all the lore and details and whatever are documented on fan blogs, but I was really paying attention and I still didn't understand the plot or what was motivating the characters much of the time. At some point, I just stopped caring too.
I really don't understand why the show decided to involve magic at all. Like not pseudo magic or symbolic magic, but literal Harry Potter style magic! They were clearly trying to make some meaningful comments on race and racism, so why throw some many downright silly elements around magic books and spells and whatnot? It's some major thematic whiplash to have Emmett Till's funeral going on in one scene and then to have someone talking about invulnerability spells in the next. At best this feels like what a bunch of executives would cook up while hamfisting a difficult topic. At worst, it feels exploitative to use real world historical events as the backdrop for stories involving monsters, spells, and time travel. It would take a very deft hand to pull something like that off well. Lovecraft Country is nowhere near up to the task.
The poor writing, over reliance on melodrama and cliche, and some of the fan service around revenge, romance, and wish fulfillment would be easier to overlook if Lovecraft Country didn't try so hard to prove to viewers that is has big important messages. Yet even here, the show again falls into cliche and the sort of obvious takes that fit nicely into hashtags. The show never develops its own distinct voice. Lovecraft Country is a house of the racist horrors, but fails to capture the living horror that was, and is, racism in America. And unfortunately the fantasy elements of the plot deaden the impact the real life horrors the show tries to examine.
As entertainment, Lovecraft Country is an ok guilty pleasure. Watch it for the characters and some of the fun action/adventure/horror bits. The larger season one plot is pretty garbage and you may find yourself chuckling at some of the unintentionally silly moments or cringing at some of its fumblings. Lovecraft Country just could have been so much better though. It should have been so much better.