interesting but flawed I used to have this friend. She seemed so self aware and like an open minded skeptic when we'd discuss anything supernatural because she knew I was a skeptic that wanted to be open minded. But she was actually the least self aware person I knew (I realized eventually) and very much naively believed very common things were supernatural, synchronicity, etc. One instance (of numerous things like this with her) was we were at this park and it had a like 18th century house with furniture that was open to the public. We go in and she's discussing all the negative "energy" she felt. Claiming she sensee spirit energy, like it was ghosts. I felt the exact same tension/"energy" .... But I knew it was my mold allergy. I could smell the mold and literally felt my body tense up from breathing it in... I felt anxious all the sudden and like there was a danger in there that I needed to run from. I totally go into fight or flight with certain allergies. It sucks but is a very common and normal reaction to warn the body of potential danger! Exactly what she described before I said a word. This happens every time I get around mold and I've heard numerous others explain exactly the same issues when their known mold allergy kicks in... She has lots of allergies too. She was indeed hyper aware that her body felt tense, that she found it hard to breath, and that her fight or flight kicked in... But she prescribed supernatural forces to cause this instead of logical scientific ones, like understanding her own allergies better.
I give this personal story to emphasize the people in this documentary remind me so much of her. They claim to keep a logical skepticism, but really don't. They have so much cognitive dissonance, I can feel it through the TV as I watch. They don't see that a majority of their claimed "synchronicities" (they don't go 5 minutes without mentioning them also) are them looking for something in nothing. I'm not trying to belittle these people. Humans, in general, have large amounts of cognitive dissonance. II used to natively believe similar things like this, that I now realize have logical explanation I just didn't educate myself properly like I insisted I had. They actually seem like people I'd love to have respectful debates about such things with.
I live in West Virginia, which is Mothman territory. I know a lot of the lore and the people here decently well. Some are very kind and will totally be helpful to strangers. But many are not too fond of outsiders. Very territorial. They will either give you cold stares and vague replies to make you go away (even threaten you as they have "pack" mentality) or they will totally mess with you once they know how to target your weaknesses to their advantage. These people have been so badly abused and mistreated by the coal industry, they know no better or some even find humor in it. When they visited Hellier and claimed the people acted weird towards them, that seemed "normal" to me from what I know of Appalachia. Yet it spooked them big time. I couldn't help but chuckle and think how where I grew up I was treated like that my whole life because I was transplanted from North East at a young age and my family was non religious. So they acted just like that to me/my family too, in WV!
Now, I say all this to follow up and say, despite feeling they are all very naive, I do believe there's "something" to the lore in these parts. I don't know what exactly. Other worldly or just answers in psychology/science, I don't know. So this interested me enough to keep watching to see what they dug up. But it seems overly drug out to telling the story, because they get so caught up in too many "synchronicities" that really aren't but they do badly need to believe it. (Also note I totally believe in real, legit synchronicities! I've had really real stuff line up that turned my atheist self into a believer in something more for certain!)
I also found the music to be distracting as another review stated. I have to constantly read the captioning because the music they picked for suspense is louder than the people talking. But it isn't so bad that it made me turn it off.
Also to the other review that claims this is supposed to be a mockumentary, from everything I found online that's false. Even looking at Twitter, it was tweeted by the one main person in this that it is indeed a documentary.