if you haven't seen the musical, you will probably love the movie... I have seen the musical 4 times now. I didn't really care for the movie, but please allow me to elaborate on this before you consider me one of the people who "trash" this film... 1. the guy who plays the Phantom just doesn't do it for me. He just doesn't sing the part with the passion I would have expected from such a tragic part. 2. the "artistic license" that was taken with a few of the plot points here were a little insulting but I realize that to make it to American cinema, that must have been "needed". I would have been able to overlook this if it hadn't been for the vocal "weak link" though (the Phantom). 3. Last but not least: the Phantom is a very tragic figure. Or should I say "is supposed to be"? This film paints him out to be more of a "handsome stranger" which is definitely not the way it should be. I didn't make it all the way through to the end of the film. I made it about 10% of the way through the song, "The Point of No Return" and I thought that the passion was misdirected here completely. The direction for this film (and the part of the Phantom, the CENTRAL character!!!) was flawed. I couldn't take it anymore. I know this is a very, very sad story but I just couldn't watch it feeling the way I did about the CENTRAL character's voice in this. So please, if you haven't seen the play, check out the film. But please, if you see the film and you like it - SEE THE PLAY.
That said, I was very impressed with the way this film was done, all in all. I thought all of the other singers were wonderful in this too. The woman who played Christine really amazed me. Would I recommend this? No, definitely not. Would I tell someone who I know hasn't seen the musical that they shouldn't see this? Definitely not. I WOULD, however, recommend the musical. If you liked this film, PLEASE go and see the play.