We Have Known The Days In those days, storytellers wrote interesting and ripping yarns, and filmmakers and experienced appealing actors made ripping good films.
This film as the book it came from, which I read many many years ago, is a tale and not actual history and it is not meant to be thought of that way. It's not always easy to make the bad guys get some sympathy and respect from moviegoers. And that can be especially true when the bad guys serve an over-arching evil purpose. This movie, this Director, and these actors manage to do it, at least as much as it probably could've been done. Meanwhile it's a well paced movie, with beautiful scenery, exciting action sequences, and it's an interesting tale that provides a lot of interesting things to think about had some thing like this ever been attempted.
The quibbler's that review this film down to it's minutest detail, can quibble. But I think that if you want to watch a film, that can make you actually feel something for German soldiers who are not themselves overt disgusting Nazis,
this one does it. Did such German elite soldiers exist? Probably doubtful, but again this is a tale, not actual history. It's an entertaining film and I recommend it.