With Capital Letters With capital letters
Remarkable cinematographic exercise by maestro Scott. The best film, without a doubt, of 2023. Perhaps it is too hard and intellectual work for a man of his advanced age, and it is possible that he has received technical and artistic assistance. All of that is very possible, yes. But, finally, the Scott Free brand chains together two epic stories worthy of this renowned director (if we consider, of course, that The Last Duel is a great film, as is my case), after a string of botches (I mean , in fact, to Covenant, Exodus, Counselor, Robin Hood...) that almost made me lose faith in this mentor.
More than two and a half hours that didn't seem long at all. And does anyone know why? Well, it's called "Narrative Rhythm". Exact. Something that Scorsese and Nolan (to give two recent and highly overrated examples) have lost sight of, much to my regret.
The performances are sensational, but hey, I'm not going to discover Joaquin Phoenix now. And some will say, even write, that the film fails in many ways, among others because the protagonist "does not look anything like" the real Napoleon... And I cannot help but be astonished by such statements. It's like those who watch a movie and come out saying "what a lack of historical accuracy..." Really?
Seriously, anyone who wants to know truths about General Napoleon should read books or sign up for Netflix documentaries, because this is a personal work, ladies and gentlemen. A fictionalized version of a character that existed. It is not relevant whether a Caesar really went down into the arena to fight hand to hand with a gladiator, or whether Hitler was gunned down in a neighborhood cinema by the French Resistance. This is cinema, an Artistic Expression, with capital letters, yes. And in Artistic Expressions with capital letters, the truths are just a version of the same story. And that is what a large part of film critics, whether amateurs or professionals, do not understand.
Napoleon is majestic, it is romantic, it is aesthetic and, finally, another version of the infamous emperor of the French. It is a narrative, a story, a fable, not a historical study, let that be clear to you. And the funny thing is that it has a worse rating than the artistically inconsequential cheesiness of Barbie. That should really bother you.