AVP-Requiem delivers a great Christmas Present! I'm not sure if if I'm going to be including a spoiler or not but I wanted to add my 2 cents worth as best as I can. I too am a huge fan of both the Aliens and Predator movies and this will definitely be added to my collection when it comes out on DVD! I'm probably being a little biased by giving it a 10 but it blew AVP 1 right out of the water. And Yes I too am a huge fan of the first AVP film. OK sure there are moments in the film that seemed unrealistic. However, personally I was still scared out of my wits while watching it.
Now after getting home and going to work from watching AVP2-Requiem I'm still trying to let everything settle in. I was very satisfied with all the acting, scoring, visual effects and yes even the script was very gripping. Sure there were a few scenes that were difficult to see but the fact that AVP1 made enough money to spawn a sequel even on the limited budget. I'm not sure how much money Avp2 is going to make but the first 3 showings at my local theater were sold out.
The music was very nice paying homage to the Alien and Predator movies using themes and blends of atmosphere from them. I couldn't believe that the movie was actually only short of an hour and a half (1:26) it seemed a lot longer. The fact that the movie was on limited budget I believe the Brothers Strause delivered a great Christmas present for me. I was not let down from the red ban trailer seeing the gore, action and acting. I knew what I was getting into when I went to the theater after seeing the trailer and I'm looking forward to seeing it again before it leaves. I also believe it continued from the first movie very well.
Again overall a 10 and without giving too much away it's better than the first one. It reminded me a lot what we couldn't see on LV-426 in the 2nd Alien film when the colony was taken over by the Aliens while Newt was the only survivor as Ripley and gang showed up.