Interesting take on the classic Novel and refreshing tonal shift of the 1994 version Damn people are really trashing this version huh? I personally think a lot of the harsh hazing against this new version of The Stand is coming from a swathe of Stephen King novel purists, I understand if you don't like it, but doesn't mean the show itself is bad, it just means it didn't meet your expectations. However some people have given legitimate reasons for why they think the show is bad, from unconvincing performances to terrible editing and timeline structures. Can't argue with that, and I agree with the timeline and some other things, hence why I couldn't never give this a 10 or close, but I can argue for the things it got right, and particularly some things it did really well.
Within the past month, I first watched this version, then recently just finished revisiting the original 1994 version of The Stand. I was interested in what the new one could bring and also how it compares to the old one, and also see how much of my nostalgia would ware off from a fresh viewing of the 1994 version which I hadn't seen since I was a kid. I gotta say, overall I think the modern version slightly outdoes the 94 version. Here's why;
The quality of acting is far more consistent in this one, the only really bad performance is by the new Trashcan Man (Ezra Miller), it was over the top, unrealistic and just plain annoying. If Trash is that far gone and disconnected from reality, I really don't think he would be able to expertly create bombs and expertly extract nuclear warheads. Whereas Trash in the 94 version (Matt Frewer) had some semblance of a grip on reality that shifted to schizophrenic psychosis when his past came back to haunt him from all the bullying for being so different, you could see a tortured soul and thus a twisted mind that fell in and out of reality obviously mixed with a pre-existing mental condition), so he could get a task done like build a bomb but make stupid mistakes (or God's plan all along etc) that would help eviscerate Las Vegas.
For me the 'Golden Egg' of this modern interpretation was Owen Teague. His portrayal of Harold was imo masterful. I totally bought into the maniacal spiralling descent into hate fuelled revenge, I could see his broken ego and manufactured personality, and what a stroke of genius, the scene where his true transformation really started to take shape, the shot of Harold looking menacingly into the mirror, grinding his vitriolic gears to conjure a gnarled counterfeit grin, only for the camera to move slowly to reveal a picture of Tom Cruise on his mirror, the picture showing Tom in typical Cruise fashion caught mid-pose grinning his forced, larger than life persona unto the public, and Harold in the mirrors reflection, mirroring Cruise in a warped unhinged flex. It's a wonderful shot and brilliant cinematic language. Harold's unrequited love for Frannie and his spiteful reluctance to accept her love for someone else is explored here on a much deeper level and creates some high stakes truly intense moments that had me on edge throughout certain episodes, already knowing what Harold will do but seeing it unfold in a new light was excellent storytelling, from the actors to the cinematic language used by the director/cinematographer, it was a huge highlight for me and trumped the originals effort. A large part of why I gave this version of The Stand a 7 out of 10 is because of Owen's performance, and the script for him mixed with the brilliant scenes conjured for him elevated the whole show.
Frannie (Odessa Young) is an improvement in this version, she has far more believable emotions conveyed on screen. However I still don't sympathise with her in either version, perhaps it's just the way the character is written in the novel (which I never read) but she comes across as slightly derogatory and condescending towards Harold. Nadine (Amber Heard) is much better here, and again has more emotional gravitas, more believable and has a better back story as to why she gives herself so willingly to Flagg. Speaking of Randall Flagg, although overall I preferred Jamey Sheridans portrayal, it's the demonic scenes and scenes where Flagg loses his temper that Alexander Skarsgard gets right here, and it was a nice touch showing a close up of Flagg's eyes and seeing into his soul, a glimpse of the universe embedded in him shown to those he chooses, and extended via the stones he gives his loyal followers/mind-controlled victims. It was a great touch too showing the more following and admirers Flagg had, the more he could levitate and access more of his powers, but as his following dwindled, he lost his ability to levitate and thus showed he relied on worship to function at maximum potential, something the first series failed to include (whether due to King's revision of the script I don't know but still, it's a pro for this version). I personally quite liked Irene Bedard as Ray, as much I am generally not a fan of wokeness being forced into all avenues of media, I felt this actually worked quite well and feel she gave more impact and 'umph' to the character and I felt more saddened by her passing than the originals Ray. Jovan Apedo overall pulled off a better performance as Larry Underwood but his backstory was a little cringe and underwhelming in places, but solid acting throughout the main storyline and again I preferred his portrayal over the 1994's version.
Whoopi Goldberg, was she there just for the paycheque? Looked like it to me, not very good, it was grating watching her miserable grimacing out lines, compared to a prior 94 Mother Abigail who was sweet and wholesome and full of life (Ruby Dee). The rotoscoped effects of Woppi's face on Mother A's deathbed were as bad as the Windows 95 hand of God effects of the 94 version. And while I'm on the matter, this version did a much better job of Mother A (im assuming teaming up with God) coming down as a storm then an electric ball and eviscerating the heathens in Las Vegas.
The biggest gripe I have with this version is episode 9. What the heck was that all about? Mr. King, did they pay you off sir? I mean, what? It was so unnecessary, it hindered the whole saga. Virtue signalling galore, and then the final scene with Flagg, somewhere between being meta and concretely setting itself up for a potential second season. Just, no. And also, we get it, white man invading bad. Other races, good. Understood. Check.
But other than that, and some highly suspect 'special' effects.. a highly enjoyable rollercoaster ride for me personally, not great but very good.