A forgettable seven in a forgettable sequel. The Magnificent Seven is a fantastic and iconic movie so it seems natural to try to replicate that magic with a sequel.
Chris, Vin, and Chico, survivors of the original return, as Chico's village is attacked and he, along with the other male villagers, are herded away.
A landowner, obsessed and driven mad by the deaths of his sons, has kidnapped men to work as slaves, rebuilding a church to act as a monument to his loss, stripping three local villages. The priest who started the rebuilding project alongside the landowner, Lorca, remains to try to keep the men alive.
Chris, finding out about the attacks, and Chico's kidnapping, quickly pulls together four men, mostly prisoners, who alongside Vin and Chico (once rescued), will form his new seven.
The seven drive off Lorca's numerically superior numbers and defend the partially rebuilt church. Lorca, driven mad by grief pulls all the men from his lands together to wipe out the seven, knowing the act will also ruin his legacy as crops will fail and herds will stray.
The final battle sees some of the seven die, but ultimately the villagers help defeat Lorca, whose death frees his men from their commitment to his insanity and the fight is done.
It's terrible.
Only Yul Brynner returns, adamant that Steve McQueen doesn't get rehired. The two men clashed in the first film as Brynner felt McQueen was always trying to upstage him. For his part, McQueen read the script and was just fine leaving this Vin to be filled by another actor, Robert Fuller stepping in to the cardboard cutout character written here.
And that's the real issue here, none of the seven are fleshed out, even Brynner, building on the legend of Chris in the original, ends up just stripping away layers of depth to be simply the leader. There's no character here.
The rest of the seven are barely fleshed out either, Warren Oates and Virgilio Teixeira effectively play the same character, a womaniser, only Warren survives and becomes a changed man, Virgilio's character dies in the final battle.
Jordan Christopher plays Manuel, a cockfighter who Chris thinks would be lucky, the character takes over Chico's role as the naive youth, only this time, while he saves the day, he doesn't make it out alive.
Only Claude Akins gets some limited meat on his bones as a gunman determined to get killed in the battle, a reversal of Robert Vaughan's Lee in the original as a gunman hiding out in the battle. Akins' Frank killed his wife in an apache raid to save her from being kidnapped by the native tribesmen. He survived that attack and has lived with the guilt, trying to get himself killed, but refusing to commit suicide. His character spends the movie standing tall in battles, refusing to take cover, finally achieving his desired end by throwing himself in front of a bullet meant for Chris (Brynner).
Julian Mateos, taking over the role of Chico is there simply to give Chris and Vin a reason to get involved, he gets little chance to show any of the bravado of Horst Buchholz's portrayal of the character. Instead he's a plot device and aside from the occasional statement that he'll put his guns away again as soon as this battle is over, may as well not be there.
Robert Fuller takes over Vin from McQueen but gets little chance to make anything out of the character, certainly not getting any of the wisecracking, fun of McQueen. It's almost certain that Brynner didn't want to take any risks here of a repeat of his experiences in the first film, and Fuller suffers for this.
Ultimately it's a poor shadow of the original, the fights are lacking any drama or danger, and when the heroes are wounded or cut down, there's little drama or tragedy, because the audience is given absolutely no reason to care.
The final battle is also almost laughable as the heroes are trapped around a raised fountain/well, not hiding effectively as they're surrounded by dozens of enemy. Fortunately Lorca's men can't aim as this should be a bloodbath.
Give this one a miss and go straight to Guns of the Magnificent Seven. It's still a poor sequel, but understands we want to know our heroes and as a result is miles superior to this.