Magnificently Preposterous Magnanimous 7, my rating, maybe even overly generous 7.
It gets 3 points for just BEING a Western, 1 more for great photography, 1 for sets and costumes, 1 for the guns & gun play, and 1 more for cast/acting (and that's a stretch). Deductions – 1 for just BEING a remake of a remake, 1 deduction for plot/screenplay preposterous enough to make the original actually look plausible, and 1 deduction for using precisely the same trading post/cabin set used in another remake, "True Grit (2010)" . . . aw c'mon, that was distracting for any Western aficionado, e.g., I kept waiting for Rooster Cogburn to kick the Indian kids off the porch! :-)
This movie reminded me of the 1950s serial Westerns, then modernized to the absolute extreme of ludicrous, over-the-top, CGI'd, special effected, shoot-em-up, you can only die three times movies. Gimme a break. Real Western movies take nearly insignificant moments and turn them into legend, Will Munny did it when he walked into that Wyoming bar on a dreary rainy night, Augustus McCray did it when he decided to chase some buffalo. But this movie ends with a shooting war so immense it would be in every history book if factual, so full of shooting deaths that the real Johnson County Range War (1892) depicted in "Heaven's Gate" (1980) looks like a mere street scuffle. Gimme a break.
Denzel Washington is a fine actor and he brings his A-game (as he always does) to his first Western, but despite a Doc Holliday-like performance by the always brooding Ethan Hawke the remaining marvelous 5 bring little to the ubiquitous poker table, not even the take-any-goofy-role Vincent D'Onofrio.
The rest of the cast, including the one obligatory female, are totally and completely forgettable, most particularly the little, trumped up weasel of a bad guy, Peter Sarsgaard . . . his character – seemingly commanding an army of 100s – would not scare anything larger than a Pomeranian. Don't think all of this matters? At 2-1/4 hours run time, trust me, it matters.
Most of all the movie breaks down on plausibility, i.e., it has none whatsoever. From the Army of the Bad to the shoot anyone looking like a bad guy theme running throughout, this is Star Wars set in the American West.
Note to anyone not a fan of Westerns even remotely thinking of watching a (real) Western, try this list first:
Lonesome Dove (1989), Open Range (2003), The Proposition (2005), Pat Garrett & Billy the Kid (1973), Missouri Breaks (1976), Dances With Wolves (1990), Unforgiven (1992), Quigley Down Under (1990), Tombstone (1993), 3:10 to Yuma (2007), The Shootist (1976), Last of the Mohicans (1992), McCabe and Mrs. Miller (1971), Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, (1969) Hang 'Em High (1968), One-Eyed Jacks (1961), Heaven's Gate (1980).