Overrated, Absurd And Devoid of Logic Color me shocked to see this episode has nearly a 10/10 rating here on IMDB.
The episode opens brilliantly, with Barry being forced to confront Ronny, whom Detective Loach wants killed because he's in a relationship with his ex-wife. Having caught Barry confessing to a myriad of crimes at the end of the previous episode (including killing Moss), Loach uses this as blackmail to force Barry to kill Ronny.
The episode opens patiently with a brilliant contrast between Ronny's casual entrance to his home, and the tension we feel as an audience knowing that Barry has to kill this guy and is probably waiting for him.
Barry, always trying to turn over a new leaf despite it being impossible, tries to get Ronny to get out of town for a year as opposed to killing him. Ronny causally agrees.
While Ronny is packing, we learn that he's a Tae Kwon Do champion all but confirming to the audience that there will be a confrontation and Barry is in deep shi**.
When the tension reaches a boiling point, Ronny strikes and the fight between him and Barry is very well executed. It's intense, comedic and extremely well choreographed and directed. There's also a sense of real stakes at play during this scene, too. Every move is desperate from Ronny's end and Barry is doing everything he can not to kill this guy, creating conflict within conflict, as Barry also has to fight for his life without doing what he does best, be a killer. It's a wonderful struggle of external and internal for the Barry character and it's just a really entertaining scene.
But everything that happens after that slowly becomes devoid of logic. This show has always tried to balance seriousness with absurdity with mixed results. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't. The initial Ronny vs. Barry fight captures this collection of moods as well as you can do it because the decisions made by the characters make sense. The majority of the rest of the episode forgets this inherent golden rule of storytelling.
Enter Lily, Ronny's pre-teen daughter after Ronny's been knocked unconscious, who is also an exceptional Tae Kwon Do martial artist (which makes sense given her Father's prowess). And this actress truly kicks ass with a lot of practical stunt work. Her fight with Barry gets a little ridiculous when she's jumping off of the floor to attack Barry, doing her best Shu Lien imitation (from Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon) and that's the tipping point for when things devolve into the absurd.
After stabbing Barry and Barry being absolutely freaked out at her seemingly inhuman abilities, she leaves with the upper hand, presumably to go to the police or a neighbor for help.
Nope. She spends the rest of her time climbing trees to evade Fuches like a simian, sitting on top of her house after climbing said tree for hours, stalking Barry and Fuches, biting Fuches' face and running away. The whole time, Barry and Fuches marvel at her over the top antics all the while Fuches wants Barry to kill her and Barry doesn't. That part of the conflict is fine, but everything Lily does makes no sense from her character's standpoint.
Why keep stalking these guys? Why not get help for your father and yourself? She literally sits on top of her house for hours. No one is going to look out their window and wonder what the hell is going on? She can't call out for help even if she doesn't have a phone? The biggest gap in logic is that in the time between when she leaves Barry and when Fuches and Barry find her again, she could have easily gone to a neighbor's house for help. It's just too silly. Disbelief can only be suspended so much, even for a comedy series that also likes be dramatic. I can't take it seriously, not in the sense that I don't see the inherent comedy in a little girl being a freak of nature, but I don't see the logic in the character's decisions. The freak of nature bit comes at the expense of the character making stupid decisions for the sake of comedy as opposed to what someone would actually do in this situation, which betrays what should be the character's obvious motivation and decisions.
It gets even more ridiculous when Fuches and Barry are at a grocery store later in the episode. Of course, Barry runs into Ronny again fitted with a neck brace. Why the hell hasn't this guy gone to the police to report Barry, or why isn't he looking for his daughter? Why is he at a grocery store?
I'm going to describe the rest of the episode and let it speak for itself.
Barry and Ronny fight again and of course Loche Dues Ex Machina's his way into the conflict and shoots Ronny in the face. Loche is about to shoot Barry to tie up loose ends but inexplicably misses the first shot despite being maybe five feet away from him. Ronny then gets up and kicks Loche to death. Ronny is shot by four or five police officers in another Deus Ex Machina moment and Barry runs away.
Fuches, in a panic, sees Barry and Ronny fighting and backs out of his parking spot and into a police car and appears to be stuck. But when Barry finds Fuches outside, he's pulled to the side of the grocery store with no repercussion for what happened despite the fact that five minutes or so have passed since he hit the cop car. The police have swarmed the grocery store, but the cop that Fuches hit I guess forgot about him.
This episode is ridiculous and makes you ask all the wrong questions about Ronny and Lily after their initial encounter with Barry.
There's a decent emotional theme with Barry passing out a couple of times due to blood loss where he imagines military veterans seeing loved ones in the opposite side of a field. Barry sees Fuches, obscured by a crowd in the middle of the field, indicating like we all know, Fuches is bad for Barry, but he can't seem to get away from him.
Barry is confronted by this emotional turmoil again in the real world by seeing Fuches outside of the grocery store, left to decide if he should keep making his deal with the devil.
That's fine, but the rest of the story isn't in my opinion. It's entertaining, but when you break down what's actually happening story and character-wise, this episode becomes increasingly frustrating. It's my least favorite episode of Barry thus far and the world's favorite. How's that for contrast?