visually astounding OK, so maybe the plot leaves a lot to be desired, although it ain't half bad, but you have to agree that visually this film is absolutely astounding. Everything looks gorgeous: the locations, the set, the set dressing, the light, the shadowing, the special effects, the CG, the everything. And the superbly mixed soundtrack only adds to the beauty.
For instance, just look at when Catherine enters Carl's mind for the first time and we are witness to his baptism; that scene is visually mindboggling.
So, you may not like the story and how it is told, but you gotta admit that it is a feast to the eyes. That's why I give it 9 out of 10!