Critique of Teen Wolf actors I've read several reviews here and agree that Tyler Posey (Scott), Crystal Reed (Allison), Colton Haynes (Jackson), and Tyler Hochlen (Derek) act very well. In fact, in my opinion, it's their acting that makes Teen Wolf interesting and gripping. I disagree, however, about Dylan O'Brien's (Stiles) role. His character is too high strung and cheesy to be believed. In fact, I find his character irritating. Holly Roden's character, Lydia, is also over the top. That said, like everyone else who has posted a review here, I'm enjoying Teen Wolf and never thought I would. The premise of the story is excellent. I like the way the writer(s) has reconstructed the werewolf myth. I sense a "sexual tension" between the main male actors that isn't explored (at least not in the early episodes I've seen). This may be an unintended dynamic on the part of the writer(s). The special effects are marvelous and not hokey. I give Teen Wolf an A-.