Made him weak before Waterloo This movie could and should have been so much better. I didn't read reviews before because I'd seen criticism at a macro level online but wanted to formulate my own opinion and its not dissimilar to what everyone else wrote.
The story wasn't nearly focused on the military leader Napoleon was. I'm not an expert by any means but felt they missed so many opportunities to delve into to the child, the man, the emperor that were left untold. He was humanized in a way that I suppose was interesting, but the character in the film never seemed as lauded and as important as history holds him. I'm not disregarding Josephine having a hold over him. Many women have had such holds over the most powerful of men, before and since. I enjoyed their love story but by NO means is that what the audience was here to see.
Fairly impressive battles, not questioning that so much. It's the lack of battle scenes that has me confused. What differentiated Napoleon was his unorthodox, guerilla style of battle, which until that time was uncommon and gave him the upper hand. The French must have passed this to the US some years earlier via Lafayette.
Take biopic out of the equation and the movie is still uneven. Everyone has some semblance of a British accent, even the Russians, French and Germans. I'd prefer a poor attempt at local accents to distinguish who they are attempting to represent than a muddled mix of various British accents, both real and attempted.
Everytime the movie begins to grip you for one reason or another, it let's you slip as quickly. I see now why they don't commonly make 2+ hour movies any longer from a studio perspective. They are hard to sell even if they are good. Irishman, Killers of the Flower Moon, etc. Have all been lackluster, self indulgent works that cater to the whims of once amazing auteurs that may have lost a step and Scott isn't immune to self aggrandizing.
I'd say skip it, but it has its moments. Just stop making 180 min plus movies that don't require it. "Less is more" is still a great idea.