Just a great film. Is the film deep, is it art cinema, is it pretentious? No. But one thing it has, is great writing. The dialogue is great,the fight scenes, whilst favouring the hero, are not outlandish but more real... (hero gets stabbed, beaten down). For an example about the writing, the woman who loses her husband asks if she can keep the letter because it has hos writing on it. Now that is touching and well delivered in a subtle unobtrusive and thus ultimately powerful way in the film. I'm sure the writer and director could make an Oscar winning masterpiece. They definitely have the ability, but this is not the genre that would appeal in that way. It's a paletable film for 15 and above without excessive or gratuitous violence. It's a crime film with ultimately loveable characters and a really satisfying progression and ending without fulfilling tired tropes. It's not a comedy but there are amusing bits in it in both the dialogue and the action (guy's head being held underwater in the water of a foot spar whilst woman who was usong the footspar looks on). The scene where one of the characters compares them to batman and robin in a cynical way is just delivered really well such that it's amusing. I just loved the way everything fitted together. For me it was better than say any of the Bourne trilogy, but possibly because it is lighter hearted and the main character is more interesting.
Really, I believe it rates as a 7 (I rarely give films an 8 or more unless veru very special) however I gave this a 8 because I think it has widespread appeal. Im not a fan of action movies, I just like good stories. Maybe the story doesn't contain too many surprises, but the delivery of the scenes and the small touches in the dialogue brings this film to life. If you like films with investigations , you'll loe it. But to be honest I can't imagine anyone that wouldn't enjoy this film. Of course, I nearly didn't watch it because of some bad reviews. I'm guessing this has more to do with them comparing it to the book and being displeased. I never read or even heard of the booo, so I can't comment on that. However I feel it's unfair to just be critical of a good film because you liked the book more. I think I'll try and find the book, but if you go into this film fresh faced, you'll love it. Watch this film. It won't change your life but if you don't like it I'll refund you the cost.. that's how confident I am that anyone would enjoy it.