A Legitimate, Non-Hyperbolic Review for a Decent Sci-Fi Drama Before I get to my review, I need to preface it by saying that I read other reviewers' comments before deciding to make my own, and the hyperbole in over-use here from other reviewers claiming that this is the "worst movie I've ever seen" or "the worst movie ever made," y'all need to grow the **** up. Or... at least see more movies before making such an absurd claim.
Is this movie "great?" No. Is it awful, like other reviewers would have you believe? Also, no. It's somewhere in the middle, but the real problem with the film and audience expectations lies with the marketing team creating a trailer that led people to believe that it's a science-fiction action thriller, and it is not. It is a solid, thought-provoking, sci-fi drama, and those are something in rather short supply these days. This film is a small, quiet, intimate, introspective exploration of the human spirit. Namely, our compassion for each other and our insatiable curiosity about the unknown.
PROS: The cast (Gary Sinise, Don Cheadle, Connie Nielsen, Jerry O'Connell, Tim Robbins, and Armin Mueller-Stahl). The production design. The (majority of the) visual effects. The original score by composer Ennio Morricone. The editing. The deliberate pace of the story. The big ideas behind the story about the possible origins of humanity.
CONS: Some really bad vfx toward the end; namely, the alien design and presentation. Gary Sinise's obvious eyeliner. And (SPOILER ALERT!!!), for a PG-rated film in the PG-13 era of more popular box office success, there is a slap-in-the-face shock visual near the beginning of the film where an astronaut is shredded to pieces by a cyclone-like, alien-made dust storm. We're talking "limb from limb" and it can be incredibly jarring for people not expecting it in a film that has been rated by the MPAA as largely being acceptable for almost all ages.
THE STORY: A second recovery team is shipped off to Mars to rescue any remaining crew members from the first Mars exploration team after communications are abruptly cut off after the aforementioned "storm" mentioned above.