La Vie Broadway After being a rent-head for many years, I was shocked to hear that not only was RENT being made into a movie, but the majority of the original cast was going to be in it. I was very pleased with hearing these news. But as time went by, I started thinking about all the ways this movie wouldn't work. One- Chris Columbus is the director (even though he did great with Harry Potter, I would have chosen many others before him). 2- Although the original cast is the only perfect cast for the show, they are a little too old for their roles and 3- It was shot in San Francisco instead of the location of the show, New York City. Even though there were these things I was worried about, I went to the movie with the highest hopes for the film.
PLOT: 8 bohemians (some with AIDS) in NYC struggle with life, love and starving to make art and beauty in the world they live in.
Here are my thoughts of the final version of the film:
DISLIKES: 1- It should have been shot in NYC. It didn't look very believable at times, especially when the snow fell. 2- :::::::SPOILERS HEREIN:::::: They SHOULD have kept "Goodbye Love." The film, the story is not the same without it. It doesn't make sense! After Angel dies, they all fight and then it goes right into "What You Own". The fight between Roger and Mark was extremely necessary to show you that these men are hurting, fighting and depressed. That song also shows you that Mimi is dying. You don't know whats going on without that part of the song :::::::END SPOILER:: 3- They should have had more of Angel and Benny. You don't sympathize with Angel that much, and you don't hate Benny as much as you do in the show because they don't have enough screen-time. Basically, after "Take Me Or Leave Me", the film failed...except for the ending.
LIKES:
1- The Cast. Everyone was amazing, and they were very believable in their roles as young starving artists. Yes, Jesse didn't look as young as the others did, but that doesn't take away from anything. 2- The Whole first half was wonderful. Best numbers were "La Vie Boheme", "Out Tonight" "Take Me Or Leave Me" "Rent" and "Tango: Maureen". 2- The ending. Thats all i'm going to say.
All in all, a great film, but it won't have the same effect on you unless you see the Broadway show first.