The Making of a Martyr Whenever I see a movie that sits around a 5-6 rating, I read the 10 star and 1 star reviews to see why it's so polarizing. I feel like this new installment of the Candyman franchise is far more nuanced than anyone seemed to mention in those reviews.
This isn't a "white people are bad" or "black empowerment" movie. It's how clinging to past injustices perpetuates a cycle of violence. Candyman isn't an avenging angel, he's a symbol of the original pain and injustice Robitaille experienced, long ago. He gains strength from injustice, and the only way he can live on is if injustice exists. He's become weaker over the generations precisely because things have become more equal. In any other movie, Anthony would be a "starving artist". Instead, he's successful enough to have a comfortable middle-class lifestyle. This is a mark of equality, not oppression. There's even direct commentary about entitled artists, which seems a little spot-on.
So, at the movie's end, the injustice has to be manufactured. Someone tipped off the police, and it's clear that Burke did so because he needed Anthony to die a martyr's death so that Candyman could return. You show me anyone that's covered in gross holes and has a hook for a hand, particularly one who has been implicated in murders, I'm probably not going to ask questions first. Same goes for burn victims with slashing razor claws, or people in hockey masks, or anything with tentacles.
It's clear that Candyman's doesn't have any "woke" motivations when he kills, he simply kills whoever's around when he's summoned. The vast majority of victims in the movie are teenage girls or all races (as seen in Burke's flashback). Does that seem "woke" to anyone?
The real horror of the movie is that people still cling to the idea of injustice as a way to justify further injustices. Murder is wrong, no matter who does it, and blood for blood isn't how to fix the world. I feel like the deaths of the teenagers show the universal truth behind the movie: when you cling to the pain of the past, children suffer. Everyone suffers. We see this all the time, with childhood depression and violence on the rise. Time to close the book on sowing division for the sake of keeping anger alive and embrace something healthier instead. This "Candyman" is a cautionary tale about what happens when you can't move on from the past.
Social commentary aside, I enjoyed the movie quite a lot. Anyone that thinks a movie can't be "horror" if the murders aren't shown on screen is missing out on decades of classic horror movies. This is true horror, bred from Burke's obsession with bringing the Candyman back to life. If you don't think it's frightening that there are people out there that are willing to sacrifice human lives to keep people divided, then you must think the daily news is a laugh riot.
I enjoyed Yahya Abdul Mateen II's performance; as I usually do. In the beginning, he seemed blissfully unaware that he, and his exploitation of the pain of others to chase the almighty dollar, is part of the problem. And then, as the realization starts to eat at him and he can no longer avoid looking at what he's becoming, he starts to detach from reality. By the end, he was literally becoming a hollowed-out husk of a person, no longer feeling the pain that consumed him. I really felt for him, because self-revelations can be gutting, and he showed that growing despondency well.
Supporting cast was good, too. I liked the comic relief Nathan Stewart-Jarrett provided and would've liked to have seen more of him (loved him in Misfits). Colman Domingo was excellent as the primary antagonist, driving the whole descent into evil, embracing the destructive concept of generational pain. He gave off really strong "crazed cultist" vibes, even if he belonged to a cult of one. Still not entirely sure why he thought bringing back the entity that killed his family was a good idea, but I suppose that's what happens when you're crazy. I feel like Teyonah Parris was underused, and Tony Todd was just there so people like me would say, "Oh! He's in this! I MUST watch it!" Lack of appropriate levels of Tony Todd is my only big complaint. I'll have to watch his scene in "Hatchet" a few dozen times to make up for it, I guess.
So, to summarize: Great, nuanced movie about how clinging to outdated concepts is destroying families. Takeaway message: Don't hold on to anger, it's a way to keep evil alive. Watch with an open mind, no matter which artificial, clickbait, media-hyped "side" you believe you're on. It's an excellent horror movie if you give it a chance, especially if you're frightened by the direction cultures around the world are being pushed towards.