"In the end, every death is just a new beginning" "Dark" has an excellent overall score here so I was excited to get started on it. It took a few episodes of season 1 to get into it, but I've experienced that with other "large-cast" programs that I ended up loving, so it's all good. But as the episodes and series wore on, I was increasingly frustrated by the show's decisions. By early in season 3, I'd had enough, but I kept plowing through to the end.
It's understandable that time travel is an enormously popular theme in entertainment, and we have a long history of successful shows that incorporate it. "Dark" does a good job putting its own twist on the concept, but the writing, plotting and direction end up failing to deliver.
Unlike shows with related themes, like "Lost," (the first few seasons) "Stranger Things" or "Fringe" (which took a while to really get rolling), "Dark" isn't well constructed. Any show that conveys a very complex story should strive to tell it straightforwardly and efficiently. Instead, "Dark" has a multitude of characters asking direct questions (like "who are you?" and "what is going on?") that are never answered by the person they're asking. With multiple worlds, alternate universes and rapid-fire time travel, it just becomes a confusing mess.
The death of any particular person becomes nearly meaningless because they can (and do) come back frequently in different timelines, making it very hard to become invested in the characters. And the frequent repetitiveness of dialogues, situations and themes becomes tiresome. The science behind the science fiction is poorly conveyed and time travel is already one of the most challenging themes to convincingly portray. Having four versions of the same person in the same room conversing with each other just pushes the envelope too far.
But there are some positives to "Dark." The acting is good to very good, and the series gets points for set design, cinematography, casting, score and sound design, CGI and effects, production values, and makeup and costume design. That's a lot of good stuff that keeps a viewer intrigued and entertained. I actually quite liked season 2 and the series finale wasn't bad (raising my score from a 5 to a 6). But with a sometimes-terrible script and poor plotting and direction, and a final season that was really just a chore to get through, there are huge gaps between "Dark" and greatness.
I recently watched a 2022 French series about time travel, "The 7 Lives of Lea," that was renewed by Netflix and it was an easy watch and I never felt it was too long or moved too slowly. It's also a fairly complex story with a different twist on the time-travel theme, but it was easy to suspend disbelief and buy into that show. I look forward to a second season of "Lea" but I already regret investing so much time with "Dark."
Some people may fall into a category that fully comprehends "Dark" and they are among the legion of fans giving it 9s and 10s. I can't criticize them and I can see how they fell in love with it. But I'm not one of them and I don't think most people are.