Solid Foundation for a Franchise Gunna start with the negatives:
While this is a good movie, it is way too long. The middle act has pacing issues towards the end of it that leads to a 3rd act that has 3 different endings. Honestly had they stopped after Falcone's arrest scene, they could've picked up from there on the sequel and it would've felt like a more natural ending.
For how grounded it is, the fact that Batman's able to take so many rounds to the chest (and no one tries to shoot his jaw off) almost feels like the film forgot it's trying to be grounded. Also, the fact that Batman was passed out long enough to be moved from the church to the police station and no one having tried to remove his mask until he wakes stands out with how otherwise smart this movie is.
They also took the Riddler and gave him a personality & motivations that would have fit Anarky much better than even a freshly started Riddler (especially with the streamer angle).
Now for the positives:
Pattison did well as Batman, and even Bruce Wayne. I know people don't like the lack of difference between the two personas, but to me it worked for a relatively naive Batman. I actually buy that this Batman has room to grow as a person and crusader.
Colin Ferrel as Penguin was easily the highlight of the movie to me. He really had fun with the material, and his jovial (for lack of a better word) portrayal brought needed levity to the movie.
Zoe Kravitz was a good Catwoman. She brought a confident sexiness to the role that was a wonderful juxtaposition to Robert Pattison's awkward & reserved Batman.
Turturro as Falcone was a wonderful surprise. I've just never seen him in this type of role, so his poise and aura as a mob boss was that much better to me.
Jeffrey Wright's Gordon was good, but I felt like some sort of hint to his backstory would've helped push his relationship with Batman a bit more (yes, I know that there's a GCPD show coming that will hopefully delve more into Gordon).
Dano's performance was solid. I didn't find him terrifying, maybe I've just seen too many flicks with psychos trying to make a point, but the brief time we spent with him as Edward Nashton was much better than his Riddler to me.
This isn't a perfect movie, but it's a really solid foundation to a franchise that I hope will culminate with the Court of Owls flexing their muscle in Gotham.
7.5/10.