Aliens don't exist in a Judeo-Christian world Time to finally talk about this travesty. I'm gonna treat this less as a review and more as cathartic therapy. What annoyed me more than any CGI monkeys, fridge nuking or Shia Lebeoufing, is that this film ignores it's own mythos.
In the first three films, we are clearly in a world where the Judeo- Christian God exists. The Ark of the Covenant is real, and so is the Holy Grail, as proved by their supernatural abilities. Admittedly, Temple of Doom is debatable, but I would argue that it still falls into the same mythical world, because if God exists, then so does Satan, the "Kali" who gives Mola Ram his powers is most likely a demon.
Which brings us to Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull. Never mind that it turns the series into Sci Fi when it has always been fantasy, what rankles me much more so, is the blatant disregard for its own world building. After walking out the cinema 8 years ago, I finally understood why Phantom Menace annoyed Star Wars fans so much. Midichlorians are the same as aliens, shoving in stuff that has no place in the universe the characters live in.
But admittedly my reasons for not liking Crystal Skull are pretty esoteric. For the average film fan, is there anything to like? Well, John Hurt's performance as an eccentric professor is good. Ray Winstone as Indy's duplicitous turncoat sidekick is fun, but I do miss John Ryhs Davies. Sallah was a great character in the series. And Sean Connery would've been great too, it's a shame that League of Extraordinary Gentlenen was such a bad experience it made him retire from acting.
The always brilliant John Williams gives an otherwise dull movie momentum, and there are one or two enjoyable character moments and action scenes. But there's a reason that this film angered so many fans of the series (Myself included). Aliens do not belong in this universe, this is Indiana Jones, not War of the Worlds.
Raiders and Last Crusade are genre classics, beloved by millions. I'm not going to pretend that Temple of Doom is a masterpiece, but at least the mine cart chase and rope bridge scene are fun. What memorable moments from Crystal Skull are there? Apart from the atomic blast survival, which is only well known because it was so over the top it started the "nuking the fridge" meme. Whenever I think of this film, all I remember is bad CGI, fake Russian accents and aliens.
And let's talk about that CGI. Every digital shot and animal sticks out like a sore thumb. ILM must have had their A team on this film, so what possible excuse could they have for such shoddy effects work? Visually speaking, the film looks nothing like the first three.
Spielberg is still one of my favorite filmmakers, but this, along with 1941 and Hook is one of his biggest missteps. Tintin, War Horse, Lincoln and Bridge of Spies were great movies though. All is forgiven Spielberg. I can't stay mad at the man who gave the world Jaws, Close Encounters, Raiders and Jurassic Park. But the rumored Indy 5 better not have sodding aliens.