Baby Yoda is so cute! And this show is highly overrated Star Wars gets a lot of hate these days and with the release of The Mandalorian fans are desperate to have something to love. I don't want to hate it, but I'm baffled by the reviews. At best, The Mandalorian is mediocre.
In our desire to forgive Disney for its mistakes, it's appears we've over-compensated by giving such high praise (and there is something suspicious about the multiple 10/10 user scores from users who've ONLY reviewed this show - and have never reviewed or scored any other Star Wars films).
The Mandalorian is the weakest written show of the subscription-service era that I've seen. It bizarrely follows the outdated model of monster/character/problem of the week. So far, they've only released five episodes, but there is little to no plot and all the characters except Mando, and his infant companion, have been superfluous. They can't even fill out the time of a standard 45-50 minute episode. Most episodes are 30-35 minutes.
When compared to its contemporaries/competitors like Stranger Things, Altered Carbon, and Lost in Space, The Mandalorian isn't even in the same league. That isn't to say it's completely inept. The title character is somewhat interesting, but everything else is hollow. All they have is a mystery-box Mcguffin in Baby Yoda, but don't expect answers any time soon because the writers don't even know, which is why every episode is basically filler.
What The Mandalorian reveals is that Disney only understands Star Wars as an aesthetic, and is still leaning heavily on nostalgia. They should have just called it: 'Star Wars Easter Eggs & References the TV Show,' because that's all it is.
Do you remember IG-88? Do you remember Thermal Detonators? Stormtroopers? Jetpacks? What about Sand-people? Or Jawas? Well good, because The Mandalorian shoehorns them all in so that the Youtubers can give them free advertising by making more 'Top 10 Things You Might Not Have Noticed In Episode 5' videos.
Strangely enough, they are inconsistent with their references and aesthetics. In Episode 5, The Mandalorian goes to Mos Eisley and travels through the desert, but he doesn't even pass by the Sarlac Pit, or the wreckage of Jaba's Barge, nor does anyone confuse him for, or mention, Boba Fett. The color of Tatooine's sand wasn't even right and thus it didn't actually look like Tatooine.
The overall production quality is inconsistent. At times it looks cinematic, and other times it looks like a Star Trek TV show - or something for the Sci-Fi channel 5 or 10 years ago. They could afford a CGI establishing shot for some village on a planet no one will remember, but when they went to Tatooine they didn't even have an establishing shot of one of Star War's most iconic locations.
The green screen matting is often Prequel-level obvious, and so far the locations have been uninteresting. They even managed to make the Mos Eisly Cantina seem like a boring place.
The Soundtrack is god-awful and it's the most distracting thing in the show. The Mandalorian title theme is a catchy rip-off of the Westworld title theme, but the rest of the score sounds like it was pre-made. It rarely fits what's on screen, often swelling to dramatic peaks in odd places. There was a scene where The Mandalorian's ship blasted off and the score made it sound like The Avengers were assembling. Yet for some reason, every time they enter a Cantina it goes dead-quiet. For all the references they put in the show, they couldn't compose fun Cantina vibes?
Overall, although the concept had potential, it's failing to execute and it's lightyears behind its peers. It isn't bad. At least it doesn't conflict with cannon, or degrade beloved characters, but it's a meager offering that hardly justifies a subscription to Disney+.